McCutcheon suggests parasocial relationships can make up for personal deficiencies - can be an escape from mundane lives
Absorption = seeking fulfilment in celeb worship motivates individual to focus attention on celeb - identity with them
Addiction = like physiological addiction , needs to increase ’dose’ of involvement to gain satisfaction- lead to extreme behaviours + delusional thinking
Attachment theory explanation
Early difficult attachment = difficult to form successful relationships later on - can lead to preference for parasocial relationships
Insecure resistant = most likely to form parasocial relationships as want to have their unfulfilled needs met where there is no real threat of rejection
Strength of parasocial: reallife application for absorption addiction model
Maltby et al studied female teens who reported an intense personal relationship with a female celeb whose body shaped they admired
Tended to have poor body image - often a precursor to an eating disorder
Supports model as shows correlation between level of celeb worship + disordered psychological functioning
Limitation of parasocial : attachment theory lacks support
McCutcheon et al found that pps with insecure attachments were no more likely to form parasocial relationships with celebs than those with secure
This contradicts the claim made by attachment theory explanations + suggests that there is no link between attachment type and parasocial relationships.
Limitation of parasocial: methodological issues
Most research uses self-reporting techniques = may not reflect the true picture ( socialdesirability bias )
Research also uses correlational analysis- can’t make causal links between body image + celeb worship
This lowers the validity of these explanations, making them less applicable to real life
Grenade
Nomothetic
Absorption-Addiction Model attempts to establish universal principles of behaviour + misses out on deep insight into the reasons for behaviour
idiographic approach may be better suited to the reasons for why people develop them