Save
...
PAPER 3 PSYCH
Issue & debates
Ethical implications
Save
Share
Learn
Content
Leaderboard
Share
Learn
Created by
monica
Visit profile
Cards (6)
Ethical implications
Ethical issues arise due to
conflict
between psychs need for valid +
valuable
research + preserving
rights
of pps
Research’s can
control
the methods they use + how they treat pps
Work can impact
public
policy + affect
perceptions
of some groups in society
Socially sensitive research
SSR= Potential social
implications
for pps in research
Examples: studies on
race
or
sexuality
Researchers should not avoid such research + may have a
social
responsibility to carry it out
Concerns for SSR
Sieber
+
Stanley
identified concerns
Implications - some studies may give
scientific
status to
discrimination
Uses - findings could be used for
wrong
purposes like shaping
public
policies
Validity - Findings presented as
objective
in the past turned out to be
fraudulent
Strength of EI:
benefits
of SSR
Scarr
argues that studies of under
represented
groups + issues may promote
greater
understanding to help reduce
prejudices
+ encourage
acceptance
E.g: research into
unreliability
of EWT has reduced risk of
miscarriages
of
justice
in legal system
Suggests SSR has
valuable
role in society
Limitation of EI: SSR can be used for
social
control
in
1920s
lot as of
US
states enacted
legislation
that led to compulsory
sterilisation
of many ppl
These ppl were judged to be
feeble
minded + a
drain
on society (e.g:
low
intelligence )
Shows that SSR has be used to prop us
discriminatory
practices in the past
Limitation of EI: Difficult to predict
cost
+
benefits
Research that carries EI is scrutinised by
ethics
committee— jobs is to
weigh
up cost + benefit of research
However, some
social
consequences involving
vulnerable
groups may be difficult to anticipate
Means assessment of research are typically
subjective
+ the real impact can only be know once’s its
public