EVALUATION

• EVALUATION?

  + scientific methods

  + leads to treatment

  -biologically determinist

  -reductionist
• SCIENTIFIC METHODS?

  • uses scientific methods of investigation
  • e.g. scanning techniques (EEG), twin studies, drug trials
  • assumptions based on objective, reliable data
  • not open to bias
• LEAD TO TREATMENT?

  • increased understanding of biology
  • lead to successful treatments
  • e.g. SSRIs used to treat OCD to balance levels of serotonin
  • real world application
  • individuals can manage own conditions rather than remain in hospital
• BIOLOGICALLY DETERMINIST?

  • too biologically deterministic
  • does not consider concept of free will
  • leads to debates about responsibility
  • can people with dysfunction MAOA gene (lead to aggressive behaviour) be held criminally responsible
• REDUCTIONIST?

  • seen as reductionist
  • reduces complex behaviour down to a single component (e.g. a chemical)
  • easier to scientifically study
  • but too simplistic