AO3: Peer review

Cards (4)

  • What are the three criticisms of peer review?
    Anonymity
    Publication bias
    Burying groundbreaking research
  • Anonymity
    Reviewers may use anonymity to criticise rival researchers; worsened by competition for funding
  • Publication bias
    More likely to publish 'headline-grabbing' findings to increase credibility and circulation of publication; some research ignored
  • Burying groundbreaking research
    May suppress opposition to mainstream theories - favourability to research that matches their view