Numerous circadian rhythms in many organs and cells in the body
These peripheral oscillators are found in the organs including the lungs, pancreas and skin are influenced by the actions of the SCN, but also act independently
Damiola et al - demonstrated how changing feeding patterns in mice could alter their circadian rhythms of cells in the liver by up to 12 hours, whilst leaving the rhythm of the SCN unaffected
This suggests other complex influences on the sleep/wake cycle.
EP AO3 - Interactionist system
Endogenous pacemakers cannot be studied in isolation
Total isolation studies, such as Michael Siffre's cave study are extremely rare
Also Siffre made use of artificial light which could have reset his biological clock every time he turned his lamp on
In everyday life, pacemakers and zeitgebers interact, and it may make little sense to separate the two for the purpose of research
This suggests the more researchers attempt to isolate the influence of internal pacemakers may lower the validity of the research
EZ AO3 - Environmental observations
Exogenous zeitgebers do not have the same effect in all environments
The experience of people who live in places where there is very little darkness in summer and very little light in winter question the importance of exogenous zeitgebers
For instance, the Inuits of the Arctic Circle are said to have similar sleep patterns all-year round, despite spending around 6 months in almost total darkness
This suggests the sleep/wake cycle is primarily controlled by endogenous pacemakers that can override environmental changes in light.
EZ AO3 - Case study evidence (counterpoint)
Evidence challenges the role of exogenous zeitgebers
Miles et al recount the study of a young man, blind from birth, who had an abnormal circadian rhythm of 24.9 hours
Despite exposure to social cues, such as regular mealtimes, his sleep/wake cycle could not be adjusted
This suggests that social cues alone are not effective in resetting the biological rhythm and light may be needed