Duress and Necessity

Cards (21)

  • What is the definition of duress in law?
    Pressure giving rise to a defense under threats
  • Why is duress considered an absolute defense at common law?
    It acknowledges human frailty in extreme situations
  • What is the first criterion in the standard test for duress?
    Specified crime must be involved
  • What does the case of Cole establish regarding duress?
    There must be a nexus between threats and crime
  • What does 'immediate threat' mean in the context of duress?
    'Imminent' threat is sufficient, not strictly immediate
  • What was the significance of the _Abdul Hussain_ case?
    It clarified that 'immediate' can mean 'imminent'
  • What type of threats are required for duress to apply?
    Threat of death or serious injury
  • What does the _Shayler_ case state about threats?
    Threat must involve death or serious injury
  • What did _Valderamme-Vega_ determine about threats?
    Threats to reveal sensitive information are insufficient
  • How is the defendant judged in terms of perceived threat?
    By their perception of the threat
  • Who can the threat be directed towards for duress to apply?
    Usually to the defendant or their family
  • What does the Graham test assess in duress cases?
    Whether the threat overbore human resistance
  • What are the two parts of the Graham test?
    Reasonable belief in threat and sober person's reaction
  • What does _Cairns_ state about the defendant's belief?
    Must have a reasonable belief in the threat
  • What characteristics are considered in the Bowen case?
    Age, sex, pregnancy, disability, mental illness
  • What are the limitations of the duress defense?
    Not available for murder or attempted murder
  • What does _Howe_ state about duress in murder cases?
    Duress is not a defense for murder
  • Under what condition is duress not available according to _Gill_?
    If the defendant could have taken evasive action
  • What does _Hasan_ state about joining a violent gang?
    Duress is not available if D joined knowingly
  • What does _Flatt_ indicate about drug dealers and duress?
    Duress is not available if D is indebted to dealers
  • How does the concept of duress relate to human behavior?
    It acknowledges the limits of human resistance