What are the strengths of Endogenous Pacemakers and Exogenous Zeitgebers
Research support from animalstudies for role of SCN
Researchsupport from humans for influence of light
Practicalapplications for jetlag
What are the limitations of endogenous pacemakers and exogenous zeitgebers
Influence of exogenouszeitgebers may be overstated
Strength = research support from animal studies for role of the SCN
Morgan (1995) - hamsters = support for suprachiasmaticnucleus
Bredhamsters so that they had abnormalcircadianrhythms of 20 hours rather than 24 hours
SCNneurons from these abnormalhamsters were transplanted into the brains of normalhamsters and SCNneurons from normalhamsters into the brains of abnormalhamsters.
The normalhamstersdisplayed the same abnormalcircadianrhythm of 20hours
Rather than maintain their abnormalcircadianrhythm the abnormalhamsters then changed to a circadianpattern of 24hours.
Strength = research support from humans for influence of light
Campbell and Murphy (1998)
15participants were awoken at varioustimes and a lightpad was shone on the back of their knees
This produced a deviation in their usualsleep-wakecycle of up to 3hours in somecases
Light is a powerfulexogenouszeitgeber that does notalwaysrely on the eyes to exert its influence on the brain
Strength = practical application for jetlag
Burgess et al. (2003) - volunteersparticipated in one of threetreatments before an east-westflight (continuousbright light, intermittentbrightlight and dimlight)
Eachshifted their sleep-wake cycle back by 1hour a day over 3days
Those exposed to continuousbrightlightprior to flight needed lesstime to readjust to localtime on arrival
Suggestslightexposure prior to a flight would allow travellers to arrive with circadianrhythmspartiallyre-entrained to localtime
Limitation = influence of exogenous zeitgebers may be overstated
Miles et al. (1977) - a youngmanblind from birth, with circadianrhythm of 24.9hours
Despiteexposure to socialcues, his sleep-wakecycle could not be adjusted and he had to take sedatives at night and stimulants in the morning to keep pace with the 24-hourworld
The study of individuals who live in arctic regions show normalsleeppatterns despite prolongedexposure to light
Examplessuggest there are occasions where exogenouszeitgebers may have littlebearing on our internalrhythm