Ontological

Cards (96)

  • What is the summary of the ontological argument?
    • God exists by definition
    • God is a being greater than which cannot be conceived
    • It is greater to exist in reality than in the mind
    • Therefore, God must exist
  • Who was the first to propose an ontological argument?
    Anselm of Canterbury
  • What does Anselm's ontological argument claim?
    God must exist because of his definition
  • How does Descartes' ontological argument differ from Anselm's?
    It uses the concept of a perfect being
  • What does Hume argue about the statement 'God does not exist'?
    It can be coherently conceived
  • What is Kant's argument regarding existence as a predicate?
    Existence does not add to a concept
  • What is Gaunilo's objection to Anselm's argument?
    Anything can be defined into existence
  • What is Malcolm's version of the ontological argument focused on?
    Necessary existence rather than existence
  • What are the key points of teleological arguments?
    • Arguments from design
    • Nature's features imply a designer
    • Similar effects have similar causes
    • The designer is God
  • Who is associated with the teleological argument in "Natural Theology"?
    William Paley
  • What analogy does Paley use to explain design in nature?
    Comparison of a watch and a stone
  • What is Hume's critique of the analogy between human-made objects and nature?
    Nature could result from natural processes
  • What does Hume argue about the causes of human designs?
    They are minds, unlike nature's designs
  • What are the problems with teleological arguments according to Hume?
    • No experience of nature's design
    • Generalizes specific designed aspects
    • Biological things lack obvious purpose
  • What is the main conclusion of Malcolm's ontological argument?
    God's existence is necessary
  • What does Malcolm argue about God's existence in relation to self-contradiction?
    The concept of God is not self-contradictory
  • How does Malcolm's argument address Kant's objection?
    It avoids the issue of existence as a predicate
  • What does Philo suggest about designs in nature?
    They could result from natural processes.
  • What analogy does Philo use regarding nature and human designs?
    Nature appears designed like human machines.
  • How does Philo differentiate between biological things and human machines?
    Biological things lack obvious purpose or designer.
  • What does Philo argue about the universe's design?
    The universe is better explained by unconscious processes.
  • What does Hume argue about order and disorder in nature?
    There is both order and disorder in nature.
  • What does Hume suggest about the existence of God based on disorder?
    God wouldn't allow such disorder if He existed.
  • What example does Hume use to illustrate spatial disorder?
    Empty areas of the universe and random rocks.
  • How does Hume relate animal suffering to the idea of a designer?
    Animals could be designed for happier lives.
  • What does Hume argue about causation?
    We only experience constant conjunction of events.
  • How does Hume illustrate the problem of inferring causation?
    Drinking tea does not cause a friend to cough.
  • What is Hume's view on the uniqueness of the universe's creation?
    We cannot infer causation from a single instance.
  • What does Hume propose about matter and time?
    Time is infinite, and matter is finite.
  • How does Hume relate finite matter and infinite time to design?
    Finite matter can appear designed over infinite time.
  • What thought experiment does Hume use to explain his point about design?
    The monkeys and typewriters analogy.
  • What does Darwin's theory explain about complex organisms?
    They can emerge without a designer through evolution.
  • How does Darwin explain the long necks of giraffes?
    Through competition for food and natural selection.
  • What is the key idea of Darwin's theory regarding adaptation?
    Adaptation creates the appearance of design over time.
  • What does Swinburne distinguish between in his argument from design?
    Spatial order and temporal order in nature.
  • How does Swinburne view the laws of nature?
    They cannot be explained scientifically like spatial order.
  • What personal explanation does Swinburne propose for the laws of nature?
    They were designed by a personal being, God.
  • What is the problem of multiple universes in relation to Swinburne's argument?
    Infinite universes could randomly support life.
  • What do Hume and Kant argue about the designer in the teleological argument?
    The designer may not necessarily be God.
  • What does the Kalam argument state about existence?
    Whatever begins to exist has a cause.