Misleading Information

Cards (9)

  • Memory is reconstructive so the original perception of the event is retrieved through the use of schemas (expectation) and is added to and refreshed each time
  • Memories can be altered when they are discussed or asked about post event - comments and questions from others can become part of the memory
  • The two variables: Post event discussion and leading questions
  • Post event discussion
    When two witnesses to a crime discuss the event with each other, the testimonies become contaminated
    This may be due to memory conformity (ISI or NSI)
    They combine information from other witnesses with their memories
  • Post event discussion - Fiona Gabbert et al (2003)
    Participants were studied in pairs - each watched a video of the same crime filmed from different point of views
    Both then discussed what they had seen
    Findings - 71% of participants mistakenly recalled aspects of the event
    Witnesses go along with each other due to memory conformity
  • Leading Questions
    Question wording can alter answers
  • Loftus and Palmer (1974)
    Participants watched clips of car accidents and then asked questions about them
    the leading question was ‘about how fast were the cars going when they hit each other’ - the word ‘hit‘ indicating speed
    Hit was changed for each group (eg smashed, bumped)
    Findings - The harsher the verb the higher the mean estimated speed
  • Response bias explanation 

    No affect on ppts memories, but influences how they answer
  • Substitution explanation
    The wording of a leading question can actually change ppts memory