Penton-Voak et al 1999 found evidence that female mate choice varies across menstrual cycle. Women typically choose feminine looking men for long-term relationships as it suggests kindness and cooperation. For short-term relationships during ovulation, the preferred appearance was masculine. This suggests genetic benefits in producing masculine offspring. However, Wood et al 2014 meta-analysis contradicts this research, specifically the claim of preferences for masculine males when females were most fertile.