Godden and Baddeley repeated their underwater, experiment (1975) but tested for the recognition of learnt words, as opposed to recall, and found no significant difference in accuracy of recognition between the matched and non-matched conditions. This suggests that retrieval failure may only explain forgetting for some types of memory, tested in specific ways and under certain conditions, so is not a universal explanation. Therefore suggests that the findings from studies of retrieval failure suffer from poor generalisability.