improving EWT accuracy

Cards (23)

  • What is the purpose of the cognitive interview?
    To improve accuracy of eyewitness testimony
  • What are some limitations of eyewitness testimony?
    Anxiety, misleading information, post-event contamination
  • Who studied witness interview techniques in Florida?
    Fisher
  • What did Fisher observe in the standard interview?
    Witnesses faced closed questions and interruptions
  • What is one feature of the cognitive interview?
    Context reinstatement
  • What does context reinstatement involve?
    Mentally returning to the crime scene
  • Why is 'report everything' important in the cognitive interview?
    It encourages recall of all details, even irrelevant ones
  • What does recalling from a changed perspective aim to do?
    Disrupt the witness's schema to reduce bias
  • How does recalling in reverse order help the cognitive interview?
    It disrupts the witness's expected chronology
  • What is an enhanced version of the cognitive interview?
    It includes additional suggestions for comfort
  • What did Fisher's field research find about the cognitive interview?
    Cognitive interview trained detectives gained more information
  • What did Kroken's meta-analysis reveal about the cognitive interview?
    It increased recall of accurate information
  • What was the accuracy rate for the cognitive interview according to Kroken's study?
    85% accuracy
  • What did Mine and Bull's study find about the cognitive interview instructions?
    No difference between each instruction's effectiveness
  • Which combination of cognitive interview aspects increased recall?
    Context reinstatement and report everything
  • What is a limitation of the cognitive interview in real-world applications?
    It takes time and requires trained officers
  • Why might police forces hesitate to use the cognitive interview?
    It requires financial resources and time
  • What is a weakness of the cognitive interview regarding identity parades?
    It is not effective for identifying subjects
  • What modified version of the cognitive interview was developed for young children?
    Modified cognitive interview by Holiday
  • For which age group was the modified cognitive interview shown to be effective?
    Four to five year olds
  • What should you do if you want to improve eyewitness testimony accuracy?
    Implement the cognitive interview techniques
  • What are the four defining features of the cognitive interview?
    1. Context reinstatement
    2. Report everything
    3. Recall from a changed perspective
    4. Recall in reverse order
  • What are the strengths and weaknesses of the cognitive interview?
    Strengths:
    • Increases amount of information recalled
    • High validity from real case studies

    Weaknesses:
    • Time-consuming
    • Requires trained officers
    • Not effective for identity parades