Neither JFK nor NK presented any significant offer as a basis for a diplomatic settlement
Brinkmanship was a high-risk strategy in international relations
Only be successful if both sides recognised that any form of military confrontation in a nuclear age would clearly be the least desirable approach
NK certainly began to rethink his position
If, as he often declared, his aim had been to protect Castro’s regime from US aggression by deploying nuclear missiles, he had clearly not succeeded
Cuba appeared to be in the greatest danger of US invasion
Less well known at the time was that JFK was willingto negotiate regarding the presence of US nuclear missiles in Turkey
The Jupiter missiles posed the same threat to the USSR as nuclear weapons in Cuba posed to the USA, making it an appropriate bargaining chip
26 Oct – JFK was still keeping his options open
Although he hadn’t rejected the idea of compromise as he said ‘we will get the strategic missiles out of Cuba only by invading Cuba or by trading’
Using force to overthrow Castro and remove the missiles remained an essential policy option for JFK
Same day – NK sent a long and rambling telegraph to JFK
NK was looking for a way out of the crisis
The basic proposal that NK was making was that if the USA made a non-invasion pledge, then the USSR would remove its military presence on Cuba
From the US point of view, this was a perfect scenario
The blockade was having no impact on the weapons systems already on Cuba
The nuclear threat was real and it was in place
A military solution was still a real option for JFK
A peaceful resolution was made more difficult at the point by Castro’s actions
He was convinced that an American attack was imminent
26 Oct – Castro ordered Cuban anti-aircraft forces to start firing on low-level reconnaissance planes
The linkage between US missiles in Turkey and Soviet missiles in Cuba had the potential to undermine any moves towards a mutual compromise agreement
ExComm violently opposed the trade-off
News came through to ExComm that a U-2 spy plane had been shot down over Cuba and the pilot, Major Rudolf Anderson, had been killed
JFK and ExComm had already committed themselves to responding to such attacks with US air attacks against Soviet S-75 anti-aircraft emplacements on Cuba
The crisis appeared to be on the brnk of escalating out of control
JFK’s strategy to recover was to ignore NK’s second letter and simply reply to the first
JFK needed to ensure that NK would accept this response
A meeting was summoned with the Soviet ambassador, Dobrynin, during which Robert Kennedy was authorised to inform him that the president was willing to remove the US missiles in Turkey – but not immediately
such a concession couldn’t be incorporated into any formal, public settlement of the crisis
JFK recognised the fairness of such a trade-off but couldn’t allow the USA’s NATO allies to view it as a concession to Soviet pressure
So important that NATO was told explicitly that no secret agreement had been reached
Diplomacy was a success
Sunday morning, 28 Oct – NK agreed to remove the missiles
JFK praised NK’s ‘statesmanlike decision’
The immediate crisis was over
Castro was incensed at what he saw as a humiliating betrayal by NK
Refused to allow inspections of the missile sits once they had been dismantled
Such checks were an essential element of the US-Soviet agreement and were only fulfilled as Soviet ships removing the missiles revealed the contents of their cargoes to US inspectors