evaluation of McCarthy's study in affects of early relationships on later relationships
+ supporting research from Bailey et al 99 women internal working model
-questionnaire lacks validity because p might not be honest and relies on accurate recollection
- researchers have exaggerated the significance of the influence of attachment on later relationships e.g. Clarke and Clarke describe the influence of infant attachment on later relationships as probabilistic. People are not doomed to always have bad relationships because they had attachment problems. They just have a greater risk of problems. By over emphasising this risk we become too pessimistic about peoples future.
-concepts of internal working models is that there are theoretical problems. Internal working models are unconscious -we are not directly aware of their influence on us. So we would not really expect to get direct evidence about them through self - report methods which require conscious awareness. When participants self-report on their relationships they are relying on their conscious understanding of those relationships. At best, self -report give us indirect evidence about internal working models