Weakness = evidence context-dependent forgetting only occurs in certain circumstances. E.g Godden & Baddeley (1980) replicated underwater experiment using recognition test instead of recall test. scuba-diver pts learnt list of words either on land or underwater. Then, either on land or underwater, they were asked to indicate whether each word from new list was on original list. Godden & Baddelely - no context-dependent effect, instead, performance = same in matching + non-matching experimental conditions. Suggests presence or absence of contextual cues only affects memory when tested in a certain way.