Financial instruments that enable their holders to obtain ordinary shares
Reduce (dilute) earnings per share (EPS) by increasing the number of shares outstanding, if converted or exercised
Examples of dilutive securities
Convertible Bonds
Convertible Preference Shares
Warrants and Employee Share Options
Basic EPS
How much income is earned by each ordinary share
Diluted EPS
How much income is earned by each ordinary share if we include all potentially converted ordinary shares
Antidilutive securities
Securities that would increase EPS, if exercised or converted, and are generally not considered in diluted EPS
Convertible bonds are accounted for as a compound financial instrument (i.e., they have both debt + equity components)
Applying the "with-and-without" approach to value convertible debt
1. Determine the total fair value of convertible debt
2. Determine the liability component by computing the net present value of all future cash flows
3. Subtract the liability component from the total fair value to get the equity component
Convertible preference shares
Provide investors with downside protection (like debt) and unlimited upside potential (like ordinary shares)
Reported as part of equity
No gain or loss recognized when converted or repurchased
Share warrants
Certificates that give the holder the right to obtain shares at a fixed price within a pre-specified period
If exercised, they become ordinary shares and usually have a dilutive effect similar to convertible securities
Holder must pay for shares
Convertible preference shares
Shares that can be converted into a fixed number of ordinary shares
Convertible preference shares
Provide investors with (some) downside protection (like debt) and unlimited upside potential (like ordinary shares)
Are not compound securities and are reported as part of equity
When converted or repurchased, there is no gain or loss recognized
A company should not recognize any gains and losses made on transactions with its own shareholders
Share warrants
Certificates that give the holder the right to obtain shares at a fixed price within a pre-specified period
Share warrants
If exercised, they become ordinary shares and usually have a dilutive effect similar to convertible securities
Holder must pay for shares
Employee share options (ESOs)
A form of warrant that give key employees the option to purchase ordinary shares at a given price over an extended period of time
Dilutive securities
Financial instruments that enable their holders to obtain ordinary shares and reduce (dilute) earnings per share (EPS) by increasing the number of shares outstanding, if converted or exercised
Effective compensation programs
Base compensation on performance
Motivate employees
Help retain executives and recruit new talent
Maximize employee's after-tax benefit and minimize employer's after-tax cost
Use performance criteria over which employee has control
Examples of dilutive securities
Convertible Bonds
Convertible Preference Shares
Warrants and Employee Share Options
Employee share options (ESOs)
Incentivize employees to act in the interest of shareholders due to the direct link between compensation and firm value
Attract highly motivated and entrepreneurial employees without (directly) expending cash (e.g., tech start-ups)
Typically structured so that only employees who remain with the firm can benefit from them, providing retention incentives
How much income is earned by each ordinary share if we include all potentially converted ordinary shares
Antidilutive securities
Securities that would increase EPS if exercised or converted, and are generally not considered in diluted EPS
Convertible bonds
Bonds that can be changed into equity shares (or other corporate securities)
Top managers used legal and illegal accounting tricks to inflate earnings (earnings management)
Reasons to invest in convertible bonds
Benefit of a bond (guaranteed interest and principal)
Exchangeable for shares (call option)
Fair-value method
Acceptable option-pricing models (e.g., Black-Scholes) are used to value the options at the grant date
Intrinsic value method
Compensation is the difference between the market price of shares and the exercise price of an option at the grant date (which is 0 if market price = option price)
Reasons to issue convertible bonds
Obtain debt financing at cheaper rates
Raise equity capital with less dilution of ownership control
Determining expense for employee share options
The total compensation expense is the fair value of the options on the date they grant them to their employees (the grant date)
Allocating compensation expense for employee share options
The compensation expense is recognized in the periods in which employees perform the service—the service period (= vesting period, if not stated otherwise)
Vesting period
The period of time that employees must wait before they can exercise their stock options
Compound financial instrument
Convertible bonds have both debt and equity components
Applying the "with-and-without" approach to value convertible bonds
1. Determine the total fair value of convertible debt
2. Determine the liability component by computing the net present value of all future cash flows
3. Subtract the liability component from the total fairvalue to get the equity component
Depends on whether the adjustment is caused by a service condition (e.g., change in vesting period) or a market condition (e.g., change in stock price)
Accounting for convertible bonds at issuance
1. Determine total fair value
2. Determine liability component by computing present value of future cash flows
3. Subtract liability component from total fair value to get equity component
Restricted shares
Shares that cannot be sold or transferred until vesting occurs
Accounting for convertible bonds at settlement
1. Repurchase at maturity
2. Conversion at maturity
3. Conversion before maturity
4. Repurchase before maturity
Restricted shares
Fair value is the market price of shares at the grant date (usually no pricing model needed)
Expensed over the service (vesting) period
Shares are issued directly at the grant date and do not become completely worthless
Convertible preference shares
Shares that enable holders to convert into a fixed number of ordinary shares
Share-appreciation rights (SARs)
Give employees the right to receive compensation equal to the increase in value (i.e., share appreciation) of their shares