James P. Spradley: '"I want to understand the world from your point of view. I want to know what you know in the way you know it. I want to understand the meaning of your experience, to walk in your shoes, to feel things as you feel them, to explain things as you explain them. Will you become my teacher and help me understand?"'
Qualitative Research
Qualitative Research
A way of understanding subjective realities or psychological phenomena
A framework, an interpretative frame
A lens
Often helps us see why something is the way it is, rather than just presenting a phenomenon
Quantitative research has features such as uses numerical indices to summarize/describe, explores relationships among traits
Qualitative research has features such as reliance on control, statistics, measurements, uses verbaldescriptions (rather than statistical report), has emphasis on studies in natural setting
Quantitative Hypothesis Testing
Describes, explains, predicts, controls, establishes facts about phenomena via numerical data
Qualitative Hypothesis Generating
Explains, explores, discovers, constructs, develops understanding and gains insight of a phenomena via collection of narrative data
Quantitative Hypothesis Testing
Confirmatory or top down, tests hypothesis and theory
Qualitative Hypothesis Generating
Exploratory or bottom-up, generates new hypothesis and theory
Quantitative Research Design Steps
Formulation of research hypothesis to be tested
Operationalize independent and dependent variables
Use appropriate statisticaltool for data analysis
Qualitative Research Design Steps
Formulation of research focus to be investigated
Narrative interview, talk and text, scripts, photos, journal entries for data collection
Coding and identifying patterns in the data
Researcher in Quantitative Research
Independent, uninvolved, results are objective
Researcher in Qualitative Research
Involved, results are subjective
Quantitative Research Design
Structured, predetermined, formal, specific
Qualitative Research Design
Evolving or emerging, flexible, informal, general
Coding
A word or phrase that symbolically assigns a summative, salient attribute that captures the essence of a language or visual data
Qualitative Data Analysis
1. Read through data to obtain general sense
2. Prepare data for analysis (e.g. transcribe fieldnotes)
3. Code the data (locate text segments and assign codes)
4. Identify patterns and themes in the coded data
Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis
Focus on understanding the meaning of human experience
Objective is to understand what personal and social experiences mean to those people who experience them
Ask participants to describe events, emotions, relationships they have
Unit of study is experiential account
Trustworthiness in Qualitative Research
Confirmability (objectivity) through triangulation, member checking, researcher reflexivity
Dependability (reliability) through dependability audits, consensus meetings, peer debriefing, bracketing
Transferability (external validity/generalizability) through thick description, data saturation
Qualitative writing becomes an unfolding story where the writer makes sense of the data and their role in the research
Unlike quantitative work, the meaning in qualitative work is in the entire text and the voice/person of the researcher as writer
Usual Writing Structure for Qualitative Research
Abstract
Introduction and Rationale
Literature Review
Methodology
Findings
Conclusions and Recommendations
Introduction in Qualitative Research
Provides preliminary background, clarifies focus, specifies aims and objectives, points out value of research
Literature Review in Qualitative Research
Evidence that the researcher is well-informed, indicates the framework, indicates what was learned from previous research and how the current research positions itself
Delayed Literature Review in Qualitative Research
Literature is introduced towards the end of the study rather than at the beginning, except for necessary 'nesting' of the problem in the introduction
Discussion in Qualitative Research
Justifies/explains the themes via responses with references to previous literature or theory, illustrates the analytical process
Conclusions in Qualitative Research
Recapitulates purpose and findings, relates to previous research, acknowledges limitations, discusses problems arising, outlines implications and recommendations, reflects on the researcher's contribution
Harper Lee: 'You never understand a person until you consider things from his point of view.'