se

• syphilitic man marrying an innocent girl

  natural law prohibited disclosure of persons medical details

  • unjust! she will get syphilissed
  • infection spreads to child
  • lack of love for ones neighbour
  • lying is dangerous and unloving here
• british intelligence during ww2 letting female agents return to germany to certain death to avoid the fact they broke the code secret

  • pragmatic
  • means was the lie of not telling the women the truth and the end was love being served, without action thousands wouldve died
  • morally just
• the catechism says that lying can be justified if it prevents greater evil or protects human dignity (CCC 2467)
• lying to schizophrenic patients

  -affirms christian love

  -pragmatic

  -allows for treatment to happen and therefore puts their needs first

  -ignores rules
• nurse making soldiers hate her to recover faster

  • personalism as it helps recovery and puts their needs first
  • is it more loving to treat them with care and respect when they're suffering? will this treatment work or make them feel worse