Unlawful Act manslaughter

Cards (15)

  • Also known as constructive manslaughter - Defendant does not have the intent to cause GBH or kill.
  • Must be an unlawful act ( Lamb )
  • An omission is not enough to create liability ( Lowe )
  • Must be a criminal offence not civil ( Franklin )
  • All sober and reasonable people must realise some risk of harm - act must be dangerous on an objective test ( Church )
  • Harm only needs to be some harm - not serious harm ( Larkin )
  • The act doesn't need to be aimed at the victim ( Mitchell )
  • The act can be directed at property ( Goodfellow )
  • Risk of harm can include suffering shock ( Dawson )
  • Factual causation - But for test ( Pagett )
  • Legal causation - More than a minimal cause - substantive and operative cause of death ( Kimsey )
  • Thin skull rule - must take the defendant how you find them ( Blaue )
  • If the act didn't kill the victim then the defendant is not liable ( Carey )
  • Intervening Acts:
    3rd party
    natural but unpredictable
    V's own acts ( Roberts )
    V's self neglect/suicide ( Wallace )
    Life support ( Malcherek )
    Drug cases (Cato=liable, Dalby=Not liable )
    Medical treatment ( Jordan )
  • the defendant only need the Mr for the act itself ( Newbury v Jones )