Critical writing, one must read to response than to react
Respond - open minded and objective
require careful study of ideas
analytical and evaluative
productive and progressive
Respond - nuanced reading
deep and detailed understanding
takes into account the "grey" areas
React - emotional and subjective
quick and shallow
emotional level than intellectual level
locked on pre-existing opinion of the reader
React - binary reading
provides only agree or disagree
do not allow for an understanding of complex arguement
Tom Chatfield
Description report information about something but they do not perform any kind of reasoning - and nor they pass judgement on or analyze the information they contain
Descriptive writing - essential element of academic writing and used to set the background and to provide evidence
Descriptive writing - informing of what you have read, done, or seen
Descriptive writing-
Reports what happened
outlines what something is
list details, information and/or options
quotes, summarizes, or paraphrase infos
states evidences
Critical Writing -
involves developing a reasoned argument and participating in academic debate
using something you have read, done or seen to persuade the reader of you position
Critical Writing
evaluates the significance
evaluates the strengths and weakness
critiques the option in order to pick the best one
compare and contrast different views
consider the relevance or validity of information from different writes
Factors of Critical Writing
thinking (elements of reasoning)
quality of your thinking ( standards to critical thinking)
Yourself as you write (character traits)
fundamental concept that are central to all writing (context, audience, communication)
Components of paper
Planning
Researching
Writing/ Drafting
Revising
Planning - Topic
general subject
Planning - Thesis statement
specific claim
claim that will be centered on the whole paper
Planning - main points
explain, support and elaborate the thesis statement
need to be back up with further supporting points
Planning -
thesis + main points = structure
skeleton or blueprint of the paper = outline
Research - essential part of writing paper
understand your topic
enrich the trustworthiness of paper
Writing/Drafting
begins with introductory part and ends with concluding section
body - thesis and main points
give credit to maintain intellectual integrity
Revising - make to change, add, subtract ideas and sharpen the paper
making the paper better
Element of reasoning -
Point of view
purpose
question at issues
information
conclusion and interpretation
concepts
assumptions
implication and consequences
Brainstorming -pre-writing technique used to identify possible aspects of the topic that your paper will pursue and identify may ideas related to the topic/subject
Freewriting - one writes freely, whatever come into the mind without caring the spelling, punctuation and more
Freewriting - increase the flow of ideas and reduce the chance that you will accidentally censor a good idea
Listing -
writing down keywords to generate ideas.
review the list and drop some ideas and focus on what is relevant
Listing
ask questions to see what turns up
observe pattern and similarities
generate question worth of its own thesis statement
Diagramming
CLustering
branching
comparing in columns
Clustering
indicate the topic or phrase summarize the topic
encircle/list down related words/ideas
Branching
example is tree diagram
from central topic to main points/ideas then to the aspects of the chief ideas
Comparing in columns - showing opposition using table
Thesis statement - states the subject matter and the main focus
Thesis statement - defines the scope and focus of the paper
Thesis statement - road map for the paper since it tells the reader what to expect form the rest of the paper