Logical problem of evil

Cards (9)

  • What is the logical problem of evil?
    If there is an omnipotent, omniscient and omnibenevolent god, why do evil and suffering exist?
  • What is the first premise?
    An omnibenevolent God would want to prevent evil
  • What is the second premise?
    An omnipotent God would be able to prevent evil
  • What is premise three?
    Yet evil and suffering exist
  • What is the conclusion?
    The God of classical theism cannot exist
  • Who came up with the inconsistent triad?
    Epicurus
  • What is the inconsistent triad?
    If we remove one aspect of the triad (evil exists, God is benevolent, God is omnipotent) the other two are compatible. All three are incompatible
  • What kind of argument is this?
    A priori
  • What does J. L. Mackie believe?
    “It is a logical problem, not a scientific problem that can be solved by observation”