José Rizal, the Philippine national hero, was sentenced to death by a court-martial for alleged rebellion, sedition, and conspiracy against the Spanish colonial government in the Philippines
Document in which Rizal retracted and denounced the anti-Catholic and anti-friar opinions expressed in his writings, particularly in his novels Noli Me Tangere and El Filibusterismo
In the retraction, Rizal declared his recognition of the Catholic Church as the only true religion and condemned the dissemination of his earlier anti-Catholic writings
Regardless of the circumstances, Rizal's retraction had a significant impact on his legacy and his standing within the Catholic Church in the Philippines
The controversy arises from conflicting interpretations of the primary sources (accounts by Pigafetta and Albo) and the lack of explicit mention of Butuan's distinct geography (river) in Pigafetta's account of the first Mass event
In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, scholars re-examined the available evidence more closely, and Pigafetta's detailed account and latitude details pointed to the island of Limasawa as being more likely the true site of the first Mass
An eyewitness account from 2011 by a Spanish sergeant named Federico Moreno provided an alternative perspective, stating that Rizal refused to sign a pre-written retraction presented by priests and instead wrote his own document hours before his execution
The debate continues between the Butuan and Limasawa claims, with both sides presenting evidence from historical sources and scholarly interpretations to make their case for the authentic location of this seminal event in Philippine historical and religious origins