God telling Abraham and Sarah they will have a son
God having total power over nature
Elizabeth having a son in old age
God doing miracles that break the laws of nature
If God is omnipotent
There can be no limits to God's power
If God is not omnipotent
He would not be able to bring about the salvation of humans by resurrecting them and giving them eternal life in heaven
The concept of omnipotence may not be coherent
If omnipotence itself isn't coherent or is impossible
Then no omnipotent being can exist
Is omnipotence compatible with the other attributes ascribed to God
e.g. being all loving as well
Is omnipotence compatible with omniscience
e.g. being able to add to His knowledge but also not be able to add to His knowledge
Descartes' view: God can do everything
God must be omnipotent because otherwise He could not implement His plan for the universe, save people from their sins, resurrect the dead, and give people eternal life in heaven
God is the source of logic so can suspend logic whenever He chooses to
Descartes' view
Compatible with many religious ideas about God being transcendent
If there is anything God cannot do, then this would suggest He is not omnipotent
God performing miracles or saving the world through Jesus supports the view that omnipotence means God can do everything
Many Christian scholars argue that Descartes' interpretation of omnipotence is flawed
Descartes' view creates a difficulty regarding the problem of evil
Aquinas' view: God can do everything that is logically possible
God can do anything which is absolutely possible, therefore ruling out that God could do the logically impossible
God cannot perform tasks that are contradictory or go against His nature
God could not
Create a being more powerful than Himself
Make Himself not powerful
Do evil
Create a race of beings with free-will who never do evil
Swinburne's view
God can do everything (where 'everything' is defined as God being able to do and create all 'things' but self-contradictory definitions are not 'things')
Kenny's view
God's omnipotence is the possession of all logically possible powers which it is logically possible for a being with the attributes of God to have
Plantinga's view
God may choose to limit his omnipotence in order to preserve free will
Vardy's view: God's power is self-limited
God decided to only operate within the natural laws he created, thus self-imposing a limitation on his power
This makes sense of God limiting himself by becoming human in Jesus Christ
God's power is more about power over the universe rather than the power to do anything
Macquarrie argues that believers need to remember they are using analogy when they talk about God's omnipotence
Almighty
The power to do anything
Some thinkers use the word 'almighty' instead of all-powerful to describe God
Peter Vardy's view of God's omnipotence
God's omnipotence is limited
God created the universe and it is so finely tuned that if God acted in a different way everything would not be able to exist as it does
God has imposed this limit on himself in order to allow the universe to remain perfectly suited for the existence of free, rational human beings
The limits God has are self-imposed, not imposed by logic, the physical world, or the actions of humans
John Macquarrie's view of God's omnipotence
Believers need to remember that they are using analogy when they talk about God's omnipotence
God's power is different to ours and there are always aspects of God's nature that we are unable to understand fully
Any limits on God's omnipotence are self-imposed, not imposed by logic, the physical world, or the actions of humans
Kenosis
The doctrine that God 'emptied' himself of omnipotence in order to come to earth as a man
Omnipotent
Having unlimited power
Almighty
Having power over everything rather than power to do everything
Geach, Whitehead and Hartshorne's view of God as almighty
It makes more sense to understand God's power as power over everything rather than power to do everything
Total power is a flawed concept as nothing or nobody can stand up to it
What is more impressive is for God to have more power over humans than any other but for humans still to be able to resist God's will
Definitions of omnipotence
God can do anything
God can do only that which is logically possible
God's power is self-limited
God is almighty
Eternal
Existing forever, without beginning or end
Interpretations of God being eternal
God is timeless (atemporal)
God is everlasting (sempiternal)
God moves through time (process theology)
Significance of whether God is eternal or timeless
Omniscience
The problem of evil
Omnipotence
Free will
Miracles
God is timeless (atemporal)
God created time and exists outside of it
God can see all events simultaneously, not limited by time
God is immutable and unchanging
Language used about God is analogical, not literal
God is everlasting (sempiternal)
God acts within time and moves along the same timeline as humans
God was, is and always will be
Swinburne's view of God in time
God is backwardly eternal (no time at which He did not exist)
God is forwardly eternal (will go on existing forever)
God exists at any nameable time
Eternal (God)
Endless duration, not timeless
Scholars who agree with eternal view of God
Charles Hartshorne
Richard Swinburne
Oscar Cullmann
Timeless God
God acts outside of time, does not move along the same timeline as humans
Everlasting God
God acts within time and as He moves along the same timeline as humans, He can act within time
Swinburne argued that if God is timeless and immutable then He cannot be a person or have a 'life' in the way that we would normally understand this