Plasticity and functional recovery evaluation strength
Maguire found that there was more grey matter in the posterior hippocampus , an area associated navigational skills, than a matched control group in the brains of taxi drivers, after learning "the knowledge" i.e. the map of London's streets for their job.
This shows that there is support for plasticity in the brain as the brains of the taxi drivers have changed through the experience of learning.
However, the study only uses taxi drivers. This is a limited sample and only tests one type of person. Lack population validity as it is not generalisable. Therefore, there is support for plasticity in the brain for taxi drivers but cannot be sure if it's the same for others. There is an issue with cause and effect.
Bezzola observed reduced motor cortex activity in novice golfers aged 40 - 60 compared to a control
Therefore, they were more efficient neurally after training, i.e. training had made their "golf brains"
This therefore shows support for plasticity in the brain as the golfer's brain had developed through the practice of golf. Also suggests plasticity continues through our lives regardless of age.
However, this was only tested with golf so it cannot be generalised to the population. Lacks external validity.