cognitive treating depression evaluation:
+evidence supporting effectiveness - compared with antidepressants CBT was just as effective + even more so when combined with drugs - widely seen as first choice in NHS
-lack of effectiveness for severe cases of depression - can't motivate themselves to engage with CBT, unsuitable for clients with LD
-high rates of relapse - concerns over long term effectiveness of CBT - 42% relapsed after 6 months
-focus on patients present - other therapies focus on links into childhood - CBT may ignore important aspects of patients of depression experiences