this study is an advancement on McClintocks study. the experimental design had high levels of control over potentially confounding variables such as sexual activity. this means a causational relationship can be established. however, the sample size was small which makes it difficult to generalise beyond the study. it also gave no explanation on why one person did not respond to the pheromones. this study is, however, consistent with the explanation that the role of pheromones is to give evolutionary advantage.