Zeitlin - Her continuing fidelity becomes the “principal anxiety that hovers over the entire poem”
Nickel - is defined by her loyalty to Odysseus
Jones - Penelope is mired in conflict and part of her desire for Odysseus’ return is because he will resolve all these issues
Finley - Penelope is “key to the unity of the poem”
Wilson - Odysseus has freedom to travel and assume multiple identities but Penelope is trapped by her marital status, either waiting for Odysseus or marrying someone else