Localisation AO3 - Higher cognitive functions not fixed
Lashley proposed the equipotentiality theory - suggests that the basic sensory and motor functions are localised but higher mental functions are not
Claimed that intact areas of the cortex could take over responsibility for specific cognitive functions following brain injury
Reduces validity about the localisation of functions, suggesting that functions are not localised to just one region, as other regions can take over specific functions following brain injury
LocalisationAO3 - Research support
Research to support localisation of functions comes from brain scan research - wide range of evidence
Peterson et al used brain scans to demonstrate how Wernicke’s area was active during a listening task and Broca’s area was active during a reading task
Tulving et al have shown that episodic and semantic memories were recalled from different sides of the prefrontal cortex whilst procedural memory is associated with the cerebellum
Localisation AO3 - Research against
Research against localisation comes from research into brain plasticity
Lashley found that when the brain becomes damaged through accident or illness and a particular function is compromised the rest of the brain is able to reorganise itself to recover the lost function, for example cases of stroke victims
Problematic as it suggests that the localisation theory may be too simplistic and the brain may be more adaptive and operate in a more holistic way
Localisation AO3 - Interactions between areas of the brain
More important to investigate how the brain areas communicate with each other, rather than focusing on specific brain regions
Wernicke - although the different areas of the brain are independent, they must interact with each other in order to function
Damage to the connection between any two points can result in impairments that resemble damage to the localised brain region associated with that specific function
Reduces the credibility of the localisation theory as functions are not limited to one area of the brain