Intrinsic rewards may be more ‘valuable’ with the individual taking part for their own gain/ benefit, i.e. satisfaction/ to win/ pride/ enjoyment
Intrinsic motivation may encourage lifelong participation/ be more long term
Intrinsic motivation is more self-sufficient
Negatives of intrinsic feedback
intrinsic motives such as fun and enjoyment may disappear due / intrinsic motivators may not be enough to maintain the motivation to participate
A cognitive learner may find it difficult and not that enjoyable so may require more than just intrinsic motivation to keep them persisting in the learning.
Benefits of extrinsic feedback
Extrinsic rewards may have more of a significant impact
Extrinsic rewards such as badges may be a very effective way to get children to start to learn a sport
Extrinsic rewards may improve confidence
Negatives of extrinsic feedback
It has been suggested that extrinsic motivation may undermine/ not be as valuable as intrinsic motivators
Extrinsic motivation may not lead to long term participation/ may lose effect
If extrinsic rewards are removed motivation may decline
may be demotivating if you don't achieve the 'level' required for extrinsic reward
Conclusions about motivation
The effect of different sources of motivation will differ for different individuals/ it is therefore hard to say one is better than the other
It depends on how much emphasis /importance is placed upon the reward/ affected by perception of reward
To increase the chances of continued participation/ performance there needs to be a balance between both types of motivation.