Ppts sat in a waiting room of a study. They overheard an altercation.
Then a man walks out with a 1. Pen (49% identified man correctly ) or 2. Knife (33% identified man correctly)
Ppts had to identify the man from 50 photos
Anxiety hinders recall
What did Parker do? (AO1)
people were interviewed after a real hurricane
Parker looked for relationship between memory of events and damage to their home
If people experienced a moderate level of anxiety - they had the most accurate recall
Anxiety helps
What did Yuille and Cutshall do? (AO1)
13 witnesses to a real bank robbery (some were threatened)
High anxiety
Interviewed immediately after by police then 4 months later by psychologists with 2 leading questions
The statements matched
Anxiety helps
What did Valentine do? (Extra AO1)
used heart rate monitoring on people visiting London dungeons labyrinth
People in 2 conditions :
High anxiety (man jumps out) - least accurate recall of perpetrator
Low anxiety ( man walks through ) - high accurate really of the perpetrator
Weapon focus - AO3 (Johnson and Scott)
if a weapon is present, we are more likely to look at that rather than the perpetrator due to fear ( need to watch weapon location for safety )
What is fight vs flight? (YuilleandCutshall AO3)
A stressful situation kicks our fight or flight system into action
Prepares our bodies physiologically
Increased heart rate - more blood to the brain and muscles, pupils dilate = physiological awareness
Physiological awareness = higher recall
Inverted-U theory ( Parker AO3 )
highest recall happens when we are moderately anxious
Inverted U on a graph (x-axis = anxiety low to high, y-axis = recall low to high)
What is Tunnel Theory (Valentine AO3)
we only focus on specific aspects of incidents, meaning we miss a lot of detail
Low anxiety =limited view of detail (unaware)
moderate anxiety = wider view of detail (aware but not overwhelmed)
high anxiety = too much detail (too aware)
Weakness of anxiety on recall - ‘surprise’
Ppts were in a hairdressers and a man walks in carrying :
A wallet (low threat, low surprise)
Scissors ( high threat, low surprise)
A rawchicken (low threat, high surprise)
Gun (high threat, high surprise)
Gun and rawchicken had the worst recall of the perpetrator
Demand characteristics weakness
In a lot of studies, ppts know they are in studies therefore are likely to change their behaviour from natural behaviour (not Parker and Yuille + Cutshall )
Lacks ecological validity in explaining the effect of anxiety