Defences

Cards (6)

  • Prescription
    • If something has occurred for 20 years or more without objection, then it is likely there will be no claim as the area has changed in nature
  • Prescription - Sturges v Bridgman
    • F: dr Built consulting room in his garden next to Sweet factory and claimed because of vibrations.
    • LP: rule that factory had been an operation for a long time with no complaint- would need to be 20 years for no nuisance
  • Statutory Authority: 

    • if the law outlines another way of resolving the issue or there are reasons written down in law for the nuisance and there is likely to be a defence
  • Planning
    • if planning application is approved and changes the nature of the area then subsequent noise/traffic etc will probably not be deemed nuisance
    • E.g. Allen v Gulf oil Refinery
  • Allen v Gulf Oil Refinery
    • F: residence near oil refinery bought a nuisance action.D’s statutory for a teacher to acquire the site and build a refinery, but not express permission to operate it
    • LP: if planning application is approved the nature of area has changed. (Is defence )
  • if the area is unchanged by planning permission, then nuisance can be used

    Coventry v Lawrence:
    • F: d bought a stadium in 2005 and had permission from 1975 from motorsports
    • Lp: claimant allowed an injunction limiting wage as the area was still considered rural in nature