'in the merciless iced east winds that knive us. . .'
The wind is personified as an attacker, stabbing the soldiers in a relentless and ruthless attack.
'Wearied we keep awake because the night is silent . . .'
Irony: The night is supposed to
bring peace and sleep,
however for the soldiers,
darkness equals vulnerability
and uncertainty.
The soldiers
cannot afford to let their guard
down at any time, therefore
they get no respite from war.
'Low drooping flares confuse our memory of the salient . . .'
Double Meaning: Their ability to think on what
is important (life, family, home, honour, loyalty, patriotism) is hazy because the flares have
dulled their priorities, as well as their sense of
direction and sight.
Repetition of ellipsis: connotes the exhausting
repetitiveness of facing one’s mortality; after every
sentence, whether they have been knived, attacked or
confused, there is a pause to symbolise a period of “unknown” – the soldiers don’t know whether they are
going to die.
As if holding their breath in anticipation of death.
'Worried by silence, sentries whisper, curious, nervous,'
Sibilance; harsh spitting sounds – mimics the whispering of the sentries whilst on guard. They are trying not to be heard or detected.
The soldiers are experiencing a
range of different emotions;
this could contribute to theirbrains aching.
'But nothing happens.'
Anticlimax: The first 4 lines are one long and continuous
sentence that has been building tension, however this is
then juxtaposed by a 3-word sentence and a full stop.
This mimics daily life for soldiers whereby the suspense of attacks sometimes amounted to nothing.
'Watching, we hear the mad gusts tugging on the wire'
The wind is so strong that is is personified as an unstable and aggressive force, violently pulling on the protective barbs around the trenches.
Nature (the real enemy) is determined for the soldiers to be defenseless and exposed. Against this, the soldiers are in fact helpless and can do nothing except
stand back and watch it happen to them.
They are nothing but passive victims.
'Like twitching agonies of men among its brambles.'
Simile: The sound from the
wind is so powerful that it
makes it seem as if men
are entangled in the wires and their bodies, writhing
and twisting in agony, are
shaking the structure.
'Northward, incessantly,'
Adverb: There is no escape from the sounds of war. They are
constant and unrelenting so the
soldiers get no release or peace
from it all.
'the flickering gunnery rumbles,'
Verbs and Sound Imagery: Even in the distance, the
sounds of war plague the soldiers, like a constant reminder. The lights from bombs and weapons flash on
and off like a light switch and create booming sounds.
'Far off, like a dull rumour of some other war'
Simile + Biblical reference: Matthew 24:6, where Jesus foretells the
end of the world. He says “You will hear of wars and rumours of wars”.
There is an apocalyptic feel to this line which gives insight into how
the soldiers would feel, so far removed from society and the normality
that comes along with it.
War exposes the dark side of human nature, therefore Owen
refrences the end of the world, where humanity and decency
ceases to exist.
When man and nature turn against you, it would
signal the end of civilization.
'What are we doing here?'
Rhetorical Question: The soldier feels that
he and his comrades are futile, fruitless
and worthless.
He completely doubts and sees no value in the war effort.
The soldier begins to question his purpose and function in the war effort; it seems like
he and his comrades regret their decision
to sign up to the war.
'The poignant misery of dawn begins to grow . . .'
Juxtaposition: whereas the dawning of a
new day is supposed to symbolise hope,
possibility and opportunity, for the soldiers it represents only a continuation of their
suffering.
Ellipsis: As if the ‘poignant misery’ has no ending. It is ongoing and all the soldiers can do is wait and endure through it.
'We only know war lasts, rain soaks, and clouds sag stormy.'
Hyperbole: The elements and their effects have
overwhelmed the minds of the soldiers; they have
lost all other knowledge and intelligence other than
this.
They are robbed of the nuances of life; the
normal uncertainties and unpredictability of life
which make it interest are gone. As such, their fates are sealed.
Full Stop: limiting and restricting. The soldiers cannot have access to anything other than suffering at the
hands of nature and time.
'Dawn massing in the east her melancholy army'
Personification: Dawn is described as the
soldier’s enemy, despite them (ironically) being
at war with men; what the new day brings is
what the soldiers are truly killed by: the
elements and the exposure.
The natural world
has marshaled against them and attempts to
strike them down.
'Attacks once more in ranks on shivering ranks of grey'
Military language is turned on its head in this stanza and is used as a
weapon against the soldiers.
But nothing happens.'
Repetition: The last line from stanza 1 reappears, however with a different meaning.
Unlike the first stanza
where everything was speculation and truly, “nothing happened”, this third stanza does report of occurrences
(rain soaking, clouds sagging and dawn’s army).
Therefore, “nothing happens” takes on a more political role; perhaps it refers to the lack of government aid and intervention, in order to prevent the soldiers being so exposed to the elements.
'Sudden successive flights of bullets streak the silence'
Sibilance; harsh
spitting sounds mimics the whistling
sound of bullets
flying– builds tension.
'Less deadly than the air that shudders black with snow,'
Comparative sentence & irony: Despite
being at war and therefore vulnerable to
streams of constant weapon-fire, this is not
comparable to the destruction and fatality
that the cold air brings.
Personification & Verb: This subverts
the idea of purity and whiteness that is associated with snow. Innocence
has been lost and turned into something sinister; almost a grim
reaper character.
'With sidelong flowing flakes that flock, pause, and renew'
Consonance: the repeated ‘f’ sounds mimics the relentlessness of the snow.
The snow cruelly
teases the soldiers and ceases
the attack, only to come back
stronger.
It’s a sick game and the soldiers have no choice
but to play, knowing they will
lose.
'We watch them wandering up and down the wind's nonchalance,'
Consonance: the repeated ‘w’ sounds creates quick successions of breath. This
mimics the cold of the soldiers, trying to
warm themselves amidst the ‘snow’, or it symbolises the whipping motion of snow in a blizzard-like frenzy.
Verb: echoes the first line where the soldiers were
“watching” the wind. They are
bystanders; an audience to
the horror show that the
nature performs.
Noun: the wind is indifferent to the
suffering it is putting the soldier’s through; it is merciless, unapologetic and unsympathetic.
'But nothing happens.'
Repetition: Bullets, deadly air and snow and still the soldiers have to
endure and suffer.
'Pale flakes with fingering stealth come feeling for our faces'
Personification: The snowflakes are portrayed as assassins with missions to attach the soldiers.
There is an image of a dark, villainous character with their hands stretched out in front of them, trying to catch their victim.
It is like the snowflakes seek out the soldiers and have them as their desired prey.
Consonance: The repetition of the ‘f’ sounds creates a violent, teeth-baring movement of the mouth; a
spitting the words resembles the harshness with which the snow is attacking the soldiers.
'We cringe in holes, back on forgotten dreams, and stare,'
Verbs: The idea of passivity and helplessness reoccurs through these
verbs; ‘cringe’ suggests that the soldiers
are bending before the flakes, out of fear or apprehension.
They have
cowered and recoiled before their
supreme master.
On another level, they ‘cringe’ in a
servile manner whereby they shrink and
wince underneath the tyrannical force
of nature, whom they must obey.
'snow-dazed'
Verb: the soldiers have
become senseless; they are
helpless to the snow’s whims
and like bewildered fools,
are now ignorant and
numb.
'Deep into grassier ditches. So we drowse, sun-dozed,'
It seems as if the soldiers have
conceded the fight.
The
deep, grassy ditch foreshadows
their fate, as it resembles a grave.
For them, there is comfort in the
setting of death and they are
ready to surrender.
'Littered with blossoms trickling where the blackbird fusses'
Contrast: In their stupefied slumber,
the soldiers are able to dream
about the beauty of nature and,
half frozen by hypothermia,
imagine themselves covered in
flowers and listening to the music of birds.
'—Is it that we are dying?'
Rhetorical Question: The only
certainty in life is death and
yet the soldiers are exempt
from drawing comfort from
this bleak inevitability.
Even
in their dazed state, they
cannot relish imagination
and are forced to come
back to their grim reality.
The question also lends itself to the
speaker drifting in and out of consciousness and yet maybe
attempting to answering his first question
of “what are we doing here?; they are
there to die.
'Slowly our ghosts drag home:'
Adverb: connotes a
long, excruciating
process of dying, where
there is no end in sight,
only perpetual suffering.
Verb: after snapping out of their imagination, the soldiers force themselves to return to the
trenches, which have now (ironically) become
their home. They are reluctant and hesitant and
yet, they have nowhere else to go.
'glimpsing the sunk fires, glozed'
Verb: the soldiers are
exposed to the warm fire
but for a fleeting moment;
it has died out before they
returned home,
showcasing the cruel and
harsh reality of war.
Caesura: The pauses could signify the
speaker reflecting, now that he and
his comrades are “ghosts”, on how
people back home had lost interest in
their fate as the war dragged on.
'For hours the innocent mice rejoice: the house is theirs;'
Irony: how vermin such as rats have take over the trenches. This
exposes the true reality of war.
'Shutters and doors, all closed: on us the doors are closed'
Assonance: the elongated “oh” sounds forces the reading to move in slow motion, mimicking
the physical action of their
’ghosts’ dragging themselves
back to the trenches.
'We turn back to our dying'
Declarative Sentences: suggests that the soldiers feel rejected by the rest of the
world and therefore, with no choice left, return to their deaths, which have
become, in some twisted sense, their comfort.
With no other options available, they subsequently look forward to death and therefore return to it, like an old friend.
'Since we believe not otherwise can kind fires burn;'
The soldiers have lost their faith in the elements, specifically the warming quality of fire and the sun.
The only ‘fire’ the soldiers are
exposed to are explosions from bombs, cannons and artillery.
'Nor ever suns smile true on child, or field, or fruit'
Personification: suggests that the sun
is deceitful and untrustworthy, even
towards the most vulnerable.
The use
of the specific nouns are symbolic of organisms that need nourishment
from the sun to survive, and
yet the speaker feels as though the
sun purposely evades them, lending
itself to the idea of the sun’s cruelty.
'For God's invincible spring our love is made afraid'
Hosea 6:3: “Let us acknowledge the Lord;
let us press on to acknowledge him. As surely as the sun rises, he will appear; he
will come to us like the winter rains, like
the spring rains that water the earth.”
Spring, symbolic of life’s natural
blessings and a renewal of the
natural world, and yet the
soldiers fear this, as it represents a
renewal of their torture and
suffering.
'Therefore, not loath, we lie out here;therefore were born,'
Verb: Reminiscent of the soldiers ‘watching’, the speaker conveys how he and his comrades are simply passive receivers.
Their only function is to patiently await death; they have learnt not to hate, but only to accept.
The speaker feels as if the soldiers only function are to sacrifice
their lives for the war effort.
They were born to die.
'For love of God seems dying.'
Religious Imagery: In addition to losing
their faith in the elements, the soldiers
have also lost their trust for religion and God.
The soldiers feel that God no longer
loves them and has abandoned them.