Systematic desensitisation efficacy- Gilroy et al (EVAL POINT)
Followed up 42 patients who had been treated for spider phobia in 345 minute sessions of SD
Spider phobia assessed using a spider questionnaire, assessed responses to a spider
Control group -> treated by relaxation without exposure
At 3 months and 33 months after treatment, the SD group were less fearful than control
Shows how SD is impactful for long-term treatment
What is a strength of SD to patients? (appropriate)
Flooding and CBT are not suited for all patients, some suffer from anxiety or learning difficulties which makes it difficult to engage in the therapy
Also hard to understand what is happening which is needed for it to be effective
SD is therefore probably most appropriate and can be used on a diverse range of patients, improving the likelihood their QOL will be improved
What is a strength of SD to patients (2)?
Most patients prefer it as it is less traumatic than flooding
Also involves pleasant relaxing procedures will makes the therapy more bearable and effective as sufferers will engage properly
Reflected in the low refusal rates and low attirtion rates
What is systematic desensitisation?
A behavioural therapy designed to gradually reduce phobic anxiety through classical conditioning
Aims for sufferers to learn a new response to the stimulus (counterconditioning)
What is counter conditioning?
Where the sufferer using the therapy learns a new response to the phobic stimulus
Usually relaxation instead of anxiety/fear
What is reciprocal inhibition?
Where one emotion prevents the other
It is impossible to be afraid and relaxed at the same time so SD aims to use relaxation to prevent the anxiety
What are the 3 processes involved in SD?
Anxiety hierarchy
Relaxation
Exposure
How is an anxiety hierarchy used?
A list of situations related to phobic stimulus that provoke anxiety
Least frightening to most frightening
The top is usually enduring/exposure to the stimulus
How is relaxation used in SD?
Therapist teaches patient relaxation techniques to use when encountering phobic stimulus
Breathing exercises, use of imagination, grounding techniques, meditation
Drugs such as valium can also be used
Patient learns these techniques to prevent and replace anxious feelings
How is exposure used in SD?
Patient is exposed to the phobic stimulus whilst in a relaxed state
Several sessions, starting from the bottom of the anxiety hierarchy
When the patient can stay relaxed in presence of lower levels of the phobic stimulus, they can move up
Treatment is successful when the patient can stay relaxed in situations high on the anxiety hierarchy
What is flooding?
A behavioural therapy in which exposure to phobic stimulus is extreme and immediate
How does flooding work?
Aims to teach the patient that the phobic stimulus is harmless through extreme exposure, removes the option for avoidance behaviour which maintains phobia
Known as extinction, where a learned response is extinguished when the CS (phobic stimulus) is encountered without the UCS (fear of it/scenario happening)
the conditioned stimulus should no longer produce the conditioned response of fear
Patient may achieve relaxation by being exhausted by their fear response
Ethical safeguards of flooding?
Patients must be able to give fully informed consent and are fully prepared before the session