Save
...
Attachment
Cultural variations of attachment
AO1
Save
Share
Learn
Content
Leaderboard
Share
Learn
Created by
Sophie
Visit profile
Cards (7)
Individualistic culture
Western cultures
that value independence and individuality
E.g
UK
and
USA
Collectivist culture
an importance of the group
Characterised by the extent to which things are shared
Groups live together, share tasks, belongings and child rearing
Value
interdependence
E.g
Japan
and
China
Van Ijzendoorn
and
Kroonenberg
- procedure
Examined
32
studies in
8
countries where the
strange situation
had been used to investigate
attachment
Had data from around
2000
children
meta analysis
- results combined but weighted for sample size
Van Ijzendoorn and Kroonenberg - findings
in all cultures
secure attachment
was the most
common
classification but it varied (e.g
britain
was
75
%,
china
was
50
%)
insecure resistant
was the
least
common
variation
within
cultures was
1.5x
greater than variation
between
cultures (e.g in
US
one study found
46
% securely attached and another found
90
%)
conclusion
the
global pattern
across cultures appears to be
similar
to that found in the US
supports the idea that
secure attachment
is best for healthy social and
emotional
development
support the idea that attachment is
innate
and
biological
cross cultural similarities
Tronick
et al
- studied an
african tribe
infants looked after and
breastfed
by different women,
slept
with own mother
infants still showed one
primary
attachment
supports
monotropy
, secure base and
Bowlbys
ideas that attachment is
innate
cross cultural differences
Grossman
and
Grossman
-
German
infants classed as
insecurely attached
German culture involves keeping some
interpersonal
behaviour
so infants dont engage in
proximity seeking
behaviour in
strange situation
- labelled insecurely attached