discuss reliability in the diagnosis of schizophrenia
- Beck: in a review of 153 patients who had been diagnosed by multiple doctors found only a 54% concordance rate between doctors assessments
--> this suggests there is a low inter-rater reliability in the diagnosis of sz and suggests many people may have been misdiagnosed leading to inappropriate treatment
discuss validity in the diagnosis of schizophrenia
- criterion validity - do different assessment systems arrive at the same diagnosis?
- Cheniaux study shoes how sz is more likely to be diagnosed using ICD than DSM, suggesting the DSM is either under diagnosing or ICD is overdiagnosing --> suggests poor validity
in the context of schizophrenia, outline what is meant by co-morbidity
when 2 conditions are frequently diagnosed together this questions the validity of their classification and diagnosis because they might be a single condition
explain how symptom overlap may lead to problems in the classification or diagnosis of schizophrenia
where conditions share many symptoms, this calls into question the validity of the theory
- eg. both sz and bipolar have the same positive symptom of hallucinations and the same negative symptom of avolition --> this calls into question the validity of the classification and diagnosis of sz and may suggest sz and bipolar may be one condition not 2
explain the issue of gender bias in the diagnosis and classification of schizophrenia
gender bias: when men and women receive different treatment towards the same condition
- longnecker found men are more often diagnoses with sz than women
--> suggests that there is gender bias in the diagnosis of sz
--> cotton et al - found women function better than men (more likely to work + have better family relationships) --> masks symptoms of sz explaining why women are under diagnosed
explain the issue of culture bias in the diagnosis and classification of schizophrenia
- afro-carribeans in the UK are up to 9x more likely to be diagnosed with sz - as rates aren't as high in their native countries it shows how it isn't genetic vulnerability but culture bias
- western definitions of mental illnesses are applied to non-western cultures eg. hearing voices of ancestors may be a religious experience in the West Indies but an auditory hallucination in the uk
discuss reliability in the diagnosis of schizophrenia
- Beck: in a review of 153 patients who had been diagnosed by multiple doctors found only a 54% concordance rate between doctors assessments
--> this suggests there is a low inter-rater reliability in the diagnosis of sz and suggests many people may have been misdiagnosed leading to inappropriate treatment