Introducing a parentocracy favours the middle class
idenitified three types of choosers
Ball - parentocracy?
Coined the phrase, suggested marketisation creates this and perpetuates inequality
Ball - privatisation?
Suggests companies expect to make up to 10x as much profit from education than other contracts
Beder - Privatisation?
UK families spent £110,000 in Tesco supermarkets in return for a single computer for schools
Hall - Privatisation?
Sees the coalition government policies (austerity) as part of the 'long march of the neoliberal revolution'
Privatisation/competition is a myth used to legitimate turning education into profit
Hancock - globalisation?
Estimated education exports from Britain by schools, universities etc to 'priority markets' abroad such as Brazil/China/Turkey were worth £18 billion to the UK economy each year
Alexander - globalisation?
PISA and TIMSS tables led to educational, economic and political moral panics over the state of British education and a search for miracle cures
Identified labour's national literacy and numeracy strategy and the coalition slimmed curriculum as examples of policies implemented as a result of international comparisons
Oates - globalisation?
Argues for international school comparisons, suggesting it is helpful to show what is humanly possible for young people to achieve at different ages
Kelly - globalisation?
Suggests it has meant education is primarily an economic activity concerned with preparing people for work and meeting the needs of the economy/employers
Durkheim - role of education?
Functionalist
2 main functions:
specialist skills and knowledge
maintaining social solidarity
Parsons - role of education?
Functionalist
Education is a bridge between home and work
Education is a meritocracy
Four factors: ascribed status, achieved status, particularistic standards, universalistic standards
Davis and Moore - role of education?
Role allocation - education sorts us according to ability, with the most able gaining higher qualifications and positions
Inequality is necessary to ensure the important roles in society are filled by the most capable
Blau and Duncan - role of education?
Functionalist
Argues a modern economy depends on human capital for prosperity
Chubb and Moe - role of education?
New Right
Called for marketisation into state education through a voucher system, in theory to prevent 'silt-shifting'/'cream-skimming'
Althusser - role of education?
Marxist
Suggests the state uses ideological state apparatus to keep power, maintained through media etc but notably education
Bowles and Gintis - role of education?
Marxist
Correspondence principle: schools are organised to achieve what the bourgeoisie want in the workplace, students learn to do what they are told or face consequences
Schooling produces obedient workers
Students with creativity/independence recieve low grades, those with obedience/discipline gain higher ones
Cohen - role of education?
Marxist
Youth training schemes serve capitalism by teaching young workers the attitude need in a subordinate labour force - lowers aspirations so the proletariat accept low paid work
Paul Willis - role of education?
Neo-marxist
Studied 12 working class boys
Concluded the working class do not live in a false class consciousness, but actively rebel against education, just ending up in the same place
Hubbs-Tait et al - class achievement?
Where parents use language that challenges their children's understanding, this enhances cognitive peformance
Feinstein - class achievement?
Argues parent's education is the most important factor affecting children's achievement
Middle class parents socialise their children through income, parenting style, education behaviours etc
Douglas - class achievement?
found working classparents place less value on education
less ambitious for their children, visited schools less often, and thus children had lower motivation and achievement
Keddie - class achievement?
describes cultural deprivation as a 'myth' and a victim-blaming explanation, refuting that school achievement cannot be blamed on a culturally deprived background as a child cannot be deprived of their own culture
Becker - class achievement?
interactionist
interviewed 60chicago teachers
found the 'ideal student' stereotpe with work, conduct and being middle class were seen as ideal
Sharp & Green - class achievement?
support interactionist views that labelling depends on backgrounds, but suggested further that negative labels on working-class children echoes wider society
Gillborn & Youdell - class achievement?
In teacher predictions of 5A*-C grades at GCSE, working class/black students were thought to be lower ability, streamed at lower sets, and entered for lower tier GCSEs
Douglas - class achievement?
Children placed in a higher stream at age 8 had an improved IQ by age 11, the opposite being true for low streams
Lacey - class achievement?
Proposed two definitions for pupil behaviours: differentiation and polarisation
Hargreaves - class achievements?
Found lower stream bots in a secondary modern school were triple failures: failed the 11+, been placed in low streams, and had been labelled 'worthless louts'
Furlong - class achievements?
Found pupils are not committed to one response but may move between them with different classes and teachers
Evans - class achievement?
Studied 21 working class alevel girls at a london comprehensive, found they were reluctant to apply to Oxford due to hidden barriers and not fitting in
Bordieu - class achievement?
Many working class students think of Oxbridge as being 'not for the likes of us'
Reay et al - class achievement?
self-exclusion from elite or distant universities narrows the options of many working-class pupils and limits their success
Gillborn & Mirza - ethnicity?
Indian pupils do well despite not having english as their first language
Moynihan - ethnicity?
Argues that because many black familise are female lone-parent families, children are deprived of care
The woman is forced to be a breadwinner and children lack a male of male achievement - this becomes cyclical
Murray - ethnicity?
Argues a high rate of lone parenthood and lack of a male role model leads to the underachievement of minorities
David - ethnicity?
Describes the National Curriculum as a 'specifically British' curriculum that largely ignores non-European language and music
Ball - ethnicity?
Criticises National Curriculum for ignoring ethnic diversity and for promoting an attitude of 'little Englandism'
Gillborn - ethnicity?
Argues marketisation gives schools more scope to select pupils, it allows negative stereotypes to influence decisions about school admissions
Moore & Davenport - ethnicity?
Researched how selection procedures lead to ethnic segregation, with minority pupils failing to get into better secondary schools due to discrimination
They found primary school reports were used to screen out pupils with language difficulties, the application was difficult to understand
Mirza - ethnicity?
Studied ambitiousblack girls who didn't achieve their aims