Separation - child away from attachment figure for brief periods of time, has no long term consequences.
Deprivation - child away from attachment figure for prolonged time, long term consequences
Effects of deprivation
Reduced intelligence
Delinquency
Aggression
Depression
Relationship difficulties
Affectionless psychopathy
Affectionless psychopathy - inability to experience guilt or strong emotion for others. Difficulty forming normal relationships
A strength of bowlbys theory of maternal deprivation is its research support from a rat study about the long term effects of maternal deprivation.
A weakness of bowlbys theory of maternal deprivation is that not all research supports it. Hilda Lewis [1954] recreated the 44 thieves study with 500 young people, and could not find a correlation with separation from the mother and criminality
A weakness of bowlbys theory of maternal deprivation is the deign flaws for the 44 thieves study. Bowlby did the affectionless psychopathy tests himself, knowing the results he wanted [ researcher bias ]
The 44 thieves study [ bowlby, 1944 ] looked at 44 teenagecriminals. They were interviewed for signs of affectionlesspsychopathy. Their families were interviewed about prolongedseparationintheearlyyears.
A control group of 44noncriminalteenagers was also used.
The findings of the 44 thrives study:
14 / 44 thieves had affectionless psychopathy.
Of that 14, 12 has prolonged speciation in early life
The control only had 2 / 44 experience prolonged separation in early life
The 44thieves study [ 1944 ] concluded that maternaldeprivationsignificantlyincreases the chances of a child developing affectionless psychopathy