disadvantages

• disadvantages of AMS - confusing

  One disadvantage of AMS is that it can be confusing.

  AMS is more difficult for voters to understand due to there being

  two votes. The system uses a complex formula to allocate seats and each person has 8 MSPs. This can lead to spoilt ballot papers which are disqualified or people not voting at all. For example, in the 2021 Scottish Parliament elections, 37% of the electorate did not turn out to vote (maybe because they didn’t understand how to).
• disadvantages of AMS - causes conflict between MSP's

  One disadvantage of AMS is that it can cause conflict between

  MSPs. As Scottish voters have 8 representatives, often from different

  parties, this can lead to confusion over who is responsible for what and

  who they can go and see if they have a problem. Constituency MSPs may be seen as more important and regional ones seen as “waste of space.” For example, our local MSP Kenneth Gibson may conflict with regional MSPs from other parties on matters in North Ayrshire.
• disadvantages of AMS - can lead to an unstable government 


  One disadvantage of AMS is that it can lead to a weak and unstable

  government. AMS increases the chances of coalition or minority governments which may be less stable than a majority government. Too much time can be wasted and law making can be slow instead of getting the job done quicker, causing frustration amongst the population. For example, the SNP has created a cooperation agreement with the Green Party to help pass legislation and has to rely on them in crucial votes.