The pathogenic smooth strain (S-type) and the non-pathogenic rough strain (R-type) were injected on mice on four different setups: (a.) the R type alone where the mouse lived, indicative of the avirulence of the R strain, (b.) the S type alone where the mouse died, attributed to the virulence of the strain, (c.) heat killed smooth strain where the mouse lived, indicative of the death or inactivation of the pathogenic agent (d.) rough strain combined with the heat killed smooth strain, both expected to allow the mouse to survive, killed the mouse.