- differences in function of hemispheres exaggerated - extent of lateralisation is exaggerated e.g. left hemisphere is specialised for language but right hemisphere is needed to understand the meaning or emotional tone
- issues of generalisation - can the results be generalised to 'normal' brains?
- control group used by Sperry had no history of epilepsy - cant tell if results are due to epilepsy or split-brain
what was the results of Sperry's study for matching faces?
- the right hemisphere also appeared dominant in terms of recognising fans
- when asked to match a face from a series of other faces, the picture presented to by right hemisphere (left visual field) was consistently selected, while the picture presented to the left hemisphere was consistently ignored
- when a composite picture made up of two different halves of a face was presented - one half to each hemisphere - the left hemisphere dominated in terms of verbal description whereas the right hemisphere dominated in terms of selecting a matching picture