Breach

Cards (5)

  • discharge by breach
    -> where one party doesn't do what they promised
    • actual breach - clear failure to do what the contract requires
    • anticipatory breach - party hints/ says outright they wont do what the contract says
    effects on conditions -> can repudiate or seek damages
    effects on warranties -> innocent party can only sue for damages
    -> before ending contract, need to be sure a condition has been broken - can be sued for wrongly ending the contract
  • actual breach
    2 ways
    1. total failure to perform - party doesnt do anything they promised
    2. failure to perform in accordance with terms of contract -> includes part performance - party doesnt do things exactly as the contract says
    repudiatory breach -> so serious it deprives innocent party to the contract of the main benefit - happens in 3 ways
    1. breach of a condition - crucial part of contract
    2. refusal to perform contract
    3. serious breach of an innominate term deemed to be a condition
  • actual breach - circumstances leading to breach 

    • where one party says they wont do what they agreed to
    • one party makes it impossible to follow the contract
    • total or partial failure to perform
    -> some contracts have termination rules - stoczinia Gdynia v Gearbulk holdings
  • anticipatory breach
    -> one party tells the other in advance they wont fulfil the contract -> direct communication through conduct
    -> can consider contract breached and sue or wait for when contract was supposed to happen and then sue
    hochester v de la tour // geden operations v drybulk handy holdings
    -> being unsure / unlikely is not a breach
  • remedies
    -> can ask for immediate compensation and must minimise losses reasonably
    -> if wait for anticipatory --> actual then losses could increase due to market changes
    -> if frustration then different remedies apply
    -> condition = repudiate/damages
    ->warranty = damages