mentakeangerofworkplaceexploitationouton their wives, eg. domestic violence
cons - outdated
Sharpe (1994) - "Just Like A Girl" study (liberal feminist)
in the past (1970s), women prioritised family, and marriage
in 1990s, working class women focused on their careers, and education
cons - only interviewed working class women
Oakley (1974) - liberal feminist
education in the family normalises inequalities
'children are passive recipients of gender roles of socialisation'
canalisation - gendered stereotypes channelled through gendered toys
Popenoe (1996)
biological imperatives exist in the family, eg. innate motherly instinct in women
Crowe (1989)
role of women has changed, eg. more financial independence
it is not necessary for gender roles as society is still able to continue with women breaking gendered barriers
Butler (1990)
3rd-wave feminist
gender is not tied to material bodily facts
gender as a social construction
Weber (1923) - Gender Pay Gap
women have less economic power, less status in the workplace and therefore have less political power
Mac an Ghaill - The making of men (1994)
conducted research in a state secondary in the British Midlands
explored how masculinities are socially constructed and regulated in a school environment
crisis of masculinity - boys face academic underachievement and unemployment
in schools boys face pressure to conform to masculine norms which impact educational experiences
some boys felt demoralised and lacked a sense of purpose due to feminism dominating the education system
Jackson (2006) - gender
there is a rise in “ladettes“
women have a “laddish” behaviour, eg. smoking
Mac an Ghail (1994) - gender
there is a “crisis of masculinity“, due to feminism and a loss of the "breadwinner" identity
Parsons (1955) - the functionalist view on gender
females have an expressive role in the family due to being maternal, reinforced by socialisation
males are the "breadwinners"
Canaan (1996) - gender
studied working class males in Wolverhampton
found that those who were employed had traditional ideas of what it meant to be a man
those who were unemployed said that having a job was the most important thing and they felt emasculated by their lack of employment
Connell (1995) - gender
hegemonic masculinity is most common in society, eg. dominance and aggression
subordinate masculinity, linked to homosexual males
marginalised masculinity, linked to unemployed men
Beechey (1986) - marxist
women as a reserve army of labour - used by capitalism when needed, can hire or fire based on the demands of capitalism
Parsons (1949) - WarmBathTheory
men expect to come home and his wife to have prepared the home, eg. a warm bath
Barron and Norris (1976) - dual labour market (Weberian theory)
the labour market is divided into two sectors: primary (well-paid jobs) and secondary (poor paid jobs)
women are more likely to be found in the secondary sector due to stereotyping, career disruption due to maternity, and the weak support of women’s rights
pros - proves that regardless of academic achievement men will always be more advantaged
Bradley (1996) - critique of Barron and Norris
fails to explain inequalities in the same sector, eg. teaching is not a secondary occupation yet women are less likely than men to gain a headteacher status
Green and Singleton (2009) - feminist
digital technology has the power to destabilise patriarchy because their use allows women to create new identities and to resist sexist representations
Equality Act (2010)
aims for anti-discrimination
Marx - women as a reserve army of labour
women are under-employed or engaged in unpaid work
this allows employed to exploit the full-time workplace by keeping wages low
Olsen and Walby (2004) - functionalist
found that women get paid less due to career breaks for maternity
the main cause of women’s low pay is “systematic disadvantage in acquiring human capital”, eg. pay is lower in occupations where there are high concentrations of women
women’s jobs provide less training than those jobs in which men are in the majority
Dalla Costa and James (2007) - marxist
women have a reproductive role in society, “women’s work” is to reproduce and raise children