Patterns

Cards (40)

  • Divorce - changes in the law
    • Equalising legal rights
    • Widening the grounds
    • Making it cheaper
    • 1971 widening the grounds made divorce rates double over night
    • Counter - doesn't explain why more people have chosen to take this freedom
  • Divorce - alternatives to law
    • Desertion
    • Legal separation (purely financial)
    • Empty shell marriage (married in name only)
    • Counter - as divorce becomes easier to obtain these have decreased
  • Divorce - declining stigma and changing attitudes (Mitchell and Goody)

    • Churches used to condemn it and refused to marry divorcees
    • Increased normality has stopped negative label
    • Today it is no longer shameful, just misfortunate
  • Divorce - secularisation
    • Traditional opposition of the churches to divorce carries less weight in society
    • People less likely to be influenced by religion
    • Churches changing their views in fear they will loose attendees
  • Divorce - rising expectations of marriage (Fletcher)

    • People less likely to tolerate an unhappy marriage
    • Increased media depiction of romantic love rises standards
    • In the past, people didn't have much choice in who they married, now they do
    • Counter - feminists say this view fails to explain why women are more likely to file for divorce
  • Divorce - women's increased financial independence
    • More likely to be in paid work
    • Equal pay laws have narrowed the pay gap
    • Girls' greater success in education gets them in higher paid jobs
    • Welfare means poorer women don't need to be dependant on their husbands
    • Allen and Crow - family is not embedded within the economic system now
  • Divorce - feminists explanation
    • Duel burden of paid work and house work
    • Hochschild - women feel more valued at work
    • Counter - Cooke and Gash found no evidence that working women are more likely to divorce
  • Divorce - modernity and individualisation (Beck and Giddens)

    • Traditional norms such as duty to remain with the same partner for life, has lost its influence over people
    • Individuals have free choice and decide when to leave a relationship
    • Rising rate emphasises that the purpose of divorce is personal fulfilment
  • High divorce reactions - the new right
    • Undesirable as it undermines marriage and traditional nuclear family
    • Thinks high divorce creates growing underclass of welfare dependent single mothers
    • Thinks this impacts health and education of kids
  • High divorce reactions - feminists
    • Desirable as it shows women are breaking free from the oppression of the patriarchal nuclear family
  • High divorce reactions - postmodernists and individualisation thesis
    • Sees it as proof of individuals realising their freedom
    • Sees it as a major cause of family diversity
  • High divorce reactions - functionalists
    • Doesn't threaten marriage as a social institution
    • Simply the result of people's higher expectations
    • Rates of re-marriage shows commitment to the idea of marriage
  • High divorce reactions - interactionalists
    • Morgan - we cannot generalise the meaning of divorce as everyone has their own story
    • Mitchell and Goody - one interviewee was happy her father left her life, one was forever upset
  • High divorce reactions - personal life perspective
    • Accepts divorce causes problems (financially and mentally)
    • Smart - sees the good in it, we should see it as just one transition amongst others in the life course
  • Partnerships - marriage
    • Fewer people are marrying, rate is at its lowest since 1920
    • Increase in re-marriages
    • People are marrying later in life
    • Couples are less likely to be married in a church
  • Partnerships - reasons for marriage patterns
    • Secularisation - all religious orgs are in favour of marriage but are loosing influence
    • Changing stigma - more diverse options more accepted
    • Women's positions - higher education and career prospects pushes family life back
    • Fear of divorce - don't want to invest time and money
  • Partnerships - increased cohabitation
    • Decline in stigma against sex outside of marriage
    • Young people more likely to accept new ideas
    • Increased career opportunities for women lessens need for financial dependence
    • Secularisation
  • Partnerships - cohabitation as a trial marriage
    • Most cases it's a temporary phase before marriage because one or both partners are awaiting a divorce
    • Bejin - young people see it as a more equal relationship dynamic
    • Shelton and John - women who cohabit do less housework than married counterparts
  • Partnerships - same sex relationships
    • Stonewall - makes up 5-7% of today's population, impossible to say if this is an increase as in the past they were hidden
    • 1967 - Male homosexual acts were criminalised for consenting males over 21
    • 2000 - age of consent was equalised with heterosexuals at 16
    • 2004 - Civil Partnership Act gave similar legal rights
    • 2014 - been able to marry
  • Partnerships - same sex relationships and chosen families
    • Weeks - increased social acceptance explains higher rates
    • Weston - SSC now decide to cohabit as stable partners, rather than the 1970s homosexual lifestyle that rejected traditional monogamy and family life
    • Counter - Allen and Crow think that because of the legal marriage only been recent, they have had to be more flexible in their relationships, making SSC less stable
  • Partnerships - one person households
    • 2019 - 3/10 households
    • Increased divorce, kids more likely to live with mother, leaving father
    • Trend of marrying later means more people are single for longer
    • Few partners available in age group, like widows
  • Partnerships - one person households and 'living apart together' (Duncan and Phillips)
    • 1/10 are LATs - in a significant relationship, but not married or cohabiting
    • Makes up for 1/2 of all the people classified as single
    • Move towards less formalised relationships
    • Or because they don't have the finances, meaning it isn't desired
    • Cannot therefore be a counter to a rejection of tradition
  • Parents and children - childbearing rates
    • Nearly half of births happen outside of marriage now (48.5%)
    • Women having children later (Average age now 30.7)
    • Women are having fewer children (2.93 in 1964 - 1.58 in 2020)
    • More women are remaining childless
  • Parents and children - reasons for childbearing rates
    • Increase in births outside of marriage due to decreased stigma
    • Later age due to women having more options other than motherhood
  • Parents and children - lone parent families rates
    • Makes up 24% of families with children
    • 1/5 kids have one parent
    • 90% are lone mothers, 10% lone fathers
    • Before 1990s they were often divorcees, since then they are often never married
    • The children are 2x as likely to live in poverty
  • Parents and children - reasons for lone parent rates
    • Increase in divorce and changing perception of marriage
    • Increase in never married women having children
    • Reasons for 90% being women:
    • Expressive role stereotype
    • Divorce courts favour women
    • Men less willing to give up work for kids
    • Renvoize - professional women can support kids without man
    • Cashmore - wc women on welfare because of abuse
  • Parents and children - lone parenthood and welfare (Murray)

    • Sees the growth as resulting from an overgenerous welfare state
    • Creates a 'perverse incentive' to have kids without being able to provide for them
  • Parents and children - counters to lone parent's welfare dependency
    • lack of affordable childcare actually deters WC from having kids
    • Welfare benefits are inadequate anyway
    • Most LP are women, who make less then men
    • Failure of fathers to pay maintenance
  • Parents and children - stepfamilies rates
    • Account for 10% in Britain
    • 85% have a kid from woman's side
    • 11% have a kid from father's side
    • 4% have a kid from both sides
    • Ferri and Smith - act like first families but are at greater risk of poverty
    • Allan and Crow - struggle with divided loyalties and contact with non-resident parent
  • Parents and children - stepfamilies rates reasons
    • Increase in divorce
    • Divorce courts favour women, explains why 85% of kids are on her side
    • Greater risk of poverty because there are more children and stepfather may have to support kids from other family
    • Lack of clear social norms about how stepfamilies should behave explains tension
  • Ethnic differences - British South Asian families (Berthoud)

    • More traditional
    • Higher rates of marriage and lower rates of cohabitation or divorce
    • Couples married younger
    • Fertility rates higher
    • Arranged marriage common among Sikhs and Muslims
    • Little intermarriage with other ethnic groups
    • Higher rate of three generation households
    • Young have strong sense of duty to elders
  • Ethnic differences - White British families (Berthoud)
    • Lower marriage and fertility rates
    • Later marriage
    • Smaller family sizes
    • Higher rates of cohabitation and divorce
    • Arranged marriages almost unknown
    • Intermarriage with other groups common
    • Once married, setting up a separate household was the norm
  • Ethnic differences - Black British Caribbean families (Berthoud)
    • Lower marriage rates
    • Similar fertility rates to Whites
    • Higher rates of lone parenthood
    • Higher rates of intermarriage with other groups, especially with Whites
  • Ethnic differences - old fashioned vs modern individualism (Berthoud)
    • Despite differences, all 3 moving towards modernity and away from tradition
    • Individual choice is more important than binding obligations
    • Caribbean families ahead on this trend, Southern Asian behind
  • Ethnic differences - changes in British Asian families
    • Bhatti - changing attitudes of young were conflicting with beliefs of elders, like when sons had chosen to marry outside the ethnic group
    • Increase in lone parenthoods - went from 10% in 1991 to 17% in 2011 for Pakistanis
    • Growing acceptance of divorce due to changing views of arranged marriage
  • Ethnic differences - changes in Black British families
    • Reynolds - statistics are misleading on lone parents, they are mostly stable LATs in reality
    • Mirza - higher rates of black lone parent families is due to high value that black women place on their independence
  • The extended family - today
    • Charles - found almost no three generation families living under the same roof in Swansea, only in the cities' Bangladeshi community
    • Counter - Willmott says they're still around but dispersed, living separately but maintain frequent contact
  • The extended family - class (Bell)
    • MC provide more financial support from father to son
    • WC provide more frequent contact as they lived closer
    • WC provides more domestic help from mothers to daughter
  • The extended family - beanpole families (Brannen)

    • Extended vertically, not horizontally
    • Increased due to closer connections between parents and kids, and a decline in support from sibling to sibling
    • Increased life expectancy makes families vertical
    • Smaller family sizes means less siblings
  • The extended family - obligations to relatives
    • Mason - over 90% of people have given or received financial help and 50% had cared for a sick relative
    • Cheal - caring most common with daughters due to expressive role, financial help most common with sons