62 out of 65 times the victim had a cane - passengers helped before the model; 19 out of 38 times the victim appeared drunk - passengers helped before the model; 81 out of 103 trials, the victim was helped before the model planned to help (71%); In 60% of the trials, more than one person helped; 90% of first helpers were male;64% of first helpers were white; 68% of helpers who aided the white victim were also white; 50% of white passengers came to the aid of a black victim; There was a tendency for same race helping if the victim appeared drunk