Is there enough control in the experiment so that it could be replicated by someone else and produce similar results. Similar results are necessary to conclude that the IV causes the DV. Are there consistent high levels of control in the experiment and are extraneous variables controlled throughout the research
Ppts in the experimental group experience the manipulated IV. Their behaviour is measured / observed to see if the manipulation has an effect on the DV
Ppts in the control group do not experience the manipulated IV. They are used as a comparison - in the control group the behaviour should be natural and in the experimental group behaviour should be different because of the manipulation
Clearly defining variables in terms of how they can be measured, otherwise the hypothesis is not testable e.g. intelligence is too vague, you need to clarify the set of behaviours or conditions that are manipulated or measured
The expected direction of the hypothesis is stated. This is the same for whether there is a positive or negative effect "higher, lower, positive, more, less"
Are the participants being studied a typical cross section of the target population - age gender culture ethnicity social class. If the sample is not representative of the target population then it is considered to be biased - the findings cannot be generalised to all people in the target population.