- Four groups of participants either asked to remember a list of: acoustically similar words, acoustically dissimilar words, semantically similar words or semantically dissimilar words.
- Participants who were asked to remember acoustically similar/dissimilar words were asked to recall after 5 mins (testing short-term memory).
- Participants who were asked to remember semantically similar/dissimilar words were asked to recall after 20 mins (testing long-term memory).
Baddeley found that participants found it most difficult to recall acoustically similar (testing short-term memory) and semantically similar (testing long-term memory) word lists.
it was reliable - took place in a laboratory setting and tested his participants' hearing prior to the experiment to make sure he did not have extraneous variables.
it may lack validity = he tested his participants' long-term memory after twenty minutes which may not have been a long enough time for them to store the memory in that particular store
there is supporting research from Baddeley's encoding study whereby short-term memory is encoded acoustically and long-term memory is encoded semantically.
- it is too simple and does not explain why, (for example) Clive Wearing lost some of his long-term memories but not all (he lost his episodic but not procedural).
This is because the words which we hear first in a list are rehearsed into our long-term memory and the words which we hear last are still in our short-term memory.
Murdock randomly selected 4000 common English words and created 20 words lists using these words ranging from 10-40 words long. He recruited 103 participants and gave them a word list to remember which they immediately read back to Murdock.