The entire set of principles, procedures, and rules established by governments through the courts and criminal legislation in order to ensure public safety
Brief history of criminal law
Code of Hammurabi established that the punishment should fit the crime
Root of law is based on English common law
Emergence of government as a meaningful source of central authority and a mechanism of collective action
Growth of professional state police services
Increasing complexity of social interaction
Modern criminal law required a body of penal law
Criminal law in Canada
Provincial and municipal police forces investigate most crimes and prosecutors working for the provincial governments prosecute most offenders
Federal government determines what acts are criminal and what available punishments apply
Federal government can enact any criminal law necessary to protect the "public, peace, order, security, health, and morality"
Most criminal laws are found in the Criminal Code and the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act
The Criminal Code of Canada (CCC)
The most important piece of legislation that the Canadian parliament has enacted within the field of criminal law
Deals with substantive criminal law and criminal procedure
Types of offenses under the CCC
Summary conviction offenses
Indictable offenses
Hybrid offenses
The criminal courts
Federal government is responsible for superior courts, including the Supreme Court of Canada, where the most severe or serious of criminal cases or appeals are managed
Provincial courts handle the majority of criminal cases as well as personal issues
The criminal trial determines the judgment on the accused's reported crime
Principle of innocent until proven guilty
Impact of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms on criminal law
The Charter ensures citizens rights are constitutionally entrenched, but these rights are not absolute
Section 1 says our rights are only subject to "such reasonable limits prescribed by law as can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society"
Sometimes as individuals Charter rights conflict with the duties and limits of the Criminal Code
The basic elements of a crime
Actus reus - the guilty act
Mens rea - the guilty mind
The actus reus element of a crime
Conduct must be voluntary
The surrounding or "material" circumstances
The consequences of the voluntary conduct
The mens rea element of a crime
Subjective mens rea: intent, knowledge, willful blindness or negligence, recklessness
Objective mens rea: focussed on negligence offenses, where the accused's actions fail to meet the standard of a "reasonable person"
Differences between classification of offenses
Absolute liability offenses
Strict liability offenses
Mens rea offenses
Inchoate offenses
Criminal attempt
Conspiracy
Counseling an offense that is not committed
Becoming party to a criminal offense: aiding and abetting
Anyone is a party to a criminal offense who: actually commits it, aids another person to commit it, abets any person to commit it
Some defenses to a criminal charge
Mental disorder
Mistake of fact
Mistake of law
Intoxication
Necessity
Duress
Self defense
Social control, discipline, and sanctions
Informal sanctions: emerge in face to face social interactions
Formal sanctions: ways to officially recognize and enforce norm violations
4 key styles of social control: penal, compensatory, therapeutic, conciliatory
Foucault's discipline and control
Render individuals docile
Hierarchical observation
Normalizing judgment
The examination
Bentham's panopticon
A social control mechanism that became a symbol for modern authority and discipline
A history of Canada's correctional system
First penitentiary in Canada built in 1835
Came under federal responsibility in 1868
Reforms in the 1960s and 1990s focused on offenders' rights and rehabilitation
Federal or provincial??
Provincial or territorial correctional facilities deal with people sentenced to 2 years (less a day), held on remand, sentenced to community service, on probation, or are children/youth
Federal correctional facilities deal with adults sentenced to 2+ years
Types of sentences
Concurrent sentence
Consecutive sentence
Intermittent sentence
Conditional sentence
The federal level: Correctional Service of Canada
Manages federal prisons with varying levels of security
Supervises offenders conditionally released into the community
Supervises sentences of two or more years in federal prison
Assists offenders to move back into the community
The provincial level: Ontario Corrections
Correctional centers house sentenced offenders serving 60 days to 2 years less a day
Detention centers hold prisoners on remand, offenders sentenced to short terms, and those awaiting transfer
Jails hold inmates until their case is resolved, who are awaiting trial or sentencing, are serving short sentences, or are awaiting transfers
Issues in the Canadian correctional system
Overcrowding
Racial profiling
Overrepresentation
Alternatives to prison: rehabilitation
Overcrowding
When the number of inmates in an institution or in a living unit exceeds its rated capacity
Increased pressure placed on correctional facilities - negative effects on inmates as well as the staff and institution
Overcrowding
Orange is the new black
Racial profiling
The act of suspecting, targeting or discriminating against a person on the basis of their ethnicity, religion, or nationality, rather than on individual suspension or available evidence
Racial profiling disproportionately affects black and indigenous individuals as well as other members of other racialized groups
Racial profiling has serious and pervasive negative impacts on individuals and communities
Canadian researchers have paid more attention to the large number of racialized people - particularly black and indigenous people - who are victimized by crimes, arrested and convicted of crimes, or both
Alternatives to prison
Rehabilitation and restorative justice
Michael Ignatieff, a former leader of the official opposition of Canada: 'Prison makes almost everybody worse who's in there'
Use of alternatives to incarceration
They give courts more sentencing options
They save taxpayers money
They strengthen families and communities
They protect the public by reducing crime
Parole
A type of community supervision generally available to offenders after serving a certain period of their sentence in prison
Probation
A type of sentence and alternative to jail, with the goal of providing a second chance to persons guilty of certain crimes
Community corrections
Supervision
Programming
Community involvement
Intermediate housing
Used as an intermediate housing option to help person return from prison to the community after serving a prison sentence
Electronic home monitoring (EHM)
Home confinement is a type of conditional sentence except that the offender serves the sentence outside of jail, under strict, jail like conditions in their home
Restorative justice
An approach to justice that seeks to repair harm by providing an opportunity for those harmed and those who take responsibility for the harm to communicate about and address their needs in the aftermath of a crime