researcher has first hand experience with informant. disguised as a participant (researcher conceals role)
observer as participant
primary role is observer, secondary is participant. their role as observer is clear but they may occasionally participate
participant as observer
primary role is participant, secondary is observer. the observer's participation is evident
complete observer
researcher observes participants without participating
observation benefits
researcher has first hand experience with informant
researcher can record information as it occurs
unusual aspects can be noticed during observation
useful exploring topics that may be uncomfortable for informants to discuss
observation disadvantages
researcher may be seen as intrusive.
“private” information may be observed that researcher cannot report.
researcher may not have good attending and observing skills.
certain informants (e.g. children) may present special problems in gaining rapport
Interviews
Face to Face
Telephone
Group
face to face
one on one, in person interview
telephone
researcher interviews via phone
group interview
researcher interviews informants in a group
advantages of interviews
useful when informants cannot be directly observed
informants can provide historical information
allows researcher “control” over the line of questioning
disadvantages of interviews
provides “indirect” information filtered through the view of interviewees
provides information in a designated “place,” rather than the natural field setting
researcher’s presence may bias responses.
not all people are equally articulate and perceptive.
Documents
Public documents
Private documents
public documents
eg. meetings, newspapers, articles, blogs
private documents
eg. diary, journal, letter
advantages of documents
enables a researcher to obtain the language and words of informants
can be accessed at a time convenient to researcher
represents data that are thoughtful in that informants have given attention to compiling
as written evidence, it saves a researcher the time and expense of transcribing.
disadvantages of interviews
may be protected information unavailable to public or private access
requires the researcher to search out the information in hard-to-find places
requires transcribing or optically scanning for computer entry
materials may be incomplete
the documents may not be authentic or accurate
Audiovisual Materials
eg. photographs, videotapes, film
advantages of audiovisual materials
may be an unobtrusive method of collecting data
provides an opportunity for informant to share directly his or her “reality”
creative in that it captures attention visually
disadvantages of audiovisual materials
may be difficult to interpret
may not be accessible publicly or privately
the presence of an observer may be disruptive and affect responses.
Data Collection Approaches in Qualitative Research
gather observational notes
keep a journal
analyze public documents
examine data
Ethical Standards of Qualitative Research
clear and written articulation of the research objectives and description of how data will be used
written permission from the informant to proceed with the study as articulated
informing the informant if all data collection devices and activities
verbatim transcriptions and written interpretations and reports will be made available to the informant
prioritizing the informant’s rights, interests, and wishes when choices are made regarding reporting the data
giving the informant the discretion to decide about his or her anonymity
Sampling in Qualitative Research
theoratical
purposive
theoretical sampling
purpose is defined by theory
purposive
purpose is not defined by a theory
features of theoretical and purposive sampling
choosing cases in terms of your theory: selecting a sample of particular processes, types, categories or examples which are relevant to appear within the wider universe
choosing deviant cases : instead of selecting a case which is likely to support your argument, seek out negative instances as defined by the theory with which you are working
changing the size of your sample during research: manipulating your sample whenever necessary
deviant case
highly unusual cases of the phenomenon of interest or cases that are considered outliers and contradicts the patterns in data, or those cases that, on the surface, appear to be the 'exception to the rule' that is emerging from the analysis
As new factors emerge, you may want to increase your sample in order to say more about them.
u may want to focus on a small part of your sample in early stages, using the wider sample for later tests of emerging generalizations.
unexpected generalizations in the course of data analysis lead you to seek out new deviant cases
Major Forms of Observation Research
Structured Observation or Systematic Observation
Participant Observation
Nonparticipant Observation
Unstructured Observation
Simple Observation and Contrived Observation
Structured Observation
systematic observation
a technique in which the researcher employs explicitly formulated rules for the observation and recording of behavior.
the rules have observation schedule used to ensure that each participant’s behavior is systematically recorded so that it is possible to group the behavior of all samples in respect to each type of behavior being recorded.
Participant Observation
best-known methods of research in social science
prolonged immersion of the observer in the social setting where he/she seeks to observe the behavior of members in the setting (group, organization, community, etc)
Nonparticipant Observation
used to describe a situation in which the observer observes but does not participate in what is going on in the social setting
Structured observers are usually nonparticipants in that they are in the social setting being observed but rarely participate in what is happening.
Unstructured Observation
does not entail the use of an observation schedule for recording of behavior
it aims to record in as much detail as possible the behavior of participants with the aim of developing a narrative account of that behavior.
Simple Observation
observer is unobtrusive and is not observed by those being observed
the observer has no influence over the situation being observed
this is a form of nonparticipant observation and can entail either structured or unstructured observation
Structured Interview
Structured approach to maximize the reliability and validity of measurement of key concepts
The interview reflects the researcher’s concerns
Rambling’ is usually regarded as a nuisance and discouraged
Structured Interview
Standardization of the interview process is strictly followed.
Inflexible due to standardization
Generates answers that can be coded and processed quickly
Unless the research is longitudinal in character, the person will be interviewed on one occasion only