Ryland v Fletcher

Cards (13)

  • Step 1
    Define Ryland v Fletcher - A person who brings / keeps on his land a dangerous thing in extraordinary + unusual circumstances is strictly liable for damaged caused by its escape
  • Step 2
    Parties
    Does C have an interest in the land to pursue a claim (Transco v Stockport)
    Is D in control of the land on which the dangerous thing is kept (Rylands v fletcher)
  • Step 3
    Accumulation
    D must of bought onto his land the dangerous thing that escapes - not a natural thing e.g. thistles (Giles v Walker)
  • Step 4
    Dangerous thing
    Thing bought onto land must be dangerous - high level of danger if it were to escape (Hale v Jennings)
  • Step 5
    Non-natural use of land, extraordinary and unusual (Rickard's v Lothian)
  • Step 6
    Escape
    Escape from land that D controls (Read v Lyons)
  • Step 7
    Damage
    Escaping thing must cause reasonable foreseeable damage (Cambridge water v Eastern countries leather)
  • Defences
    • Act of stranger
    • Act of god
    • Statutory authority
    • Volenti
    • Contributory negligence
  • Defence - act of stranger
    D not liable if escape is caused by the deliberate act of a stranger (Perry v Kendricks)
  • Defences - act of god
    A natural event so enormous that it cannot be foreseen or guarded against (Nichols v Marsland)
  • Defences - statutory authority
    D is not liable if the escape occurs during activities authorised by an act of parliament (Green c Chelsea Waterworks)
  • Defences - volenti
    No liability when C has consented (Peters v prince of Wales theatre)
  • Defences - contributory negligence
    Where C is partly responsible for the escape of the thing - damages may be reduced