Ontological arguments

Cards (3)

  • Anselm's ontological argument

    P1- God is the greatest conceivable being
    P2- it is greater to exist in the understanding and in reality, than existing in the understanding alone
    C1- therefore the greatest conceivable being, God, must exist in the understanding and in reality
    C2- Therefore God exists
  • Descartes' ontological argument

    P1- My idea of God is of a supremely perfect being
    P2- A supremely perfect being has all perfections
    P3- existence is a perfection
    C- therefore, God must exist
  • Malcolm's ontological argument 

    P1- god is an unlimited being
    P2- god's existence is either contingent, necessary, or impossible
    P3- god's existence cannot be contingent: this would mean god would be brought into or out of existence by something else, limiting God. but god is unlimited
    P4- god's existence is not impossible: this is because the concept is not self-contradictory/incoherent
    C- therefore, god's existence is necessary- god necessarily exists